Spoilers follow for Yellowjackets Season 4, Episode 1 – “Hivemind,” which is streaming now on Paramount+. New episodes drop weekly on Fridays.
In 2012, Showtime delivered Yellowjackets, its best original horror drama since Dexter. Featuring a female-led cast of middle-aged legends (Melanie Lynskey, Tawny Cypress, Christina Ricci, etc.) and mostly unknowns playing their younger selves, Yellowjackets earned instant buzz for its scary mix of survival horror, social hierarchy commentary and trauma manifestations. So it’s been hugely disappointing that the subsequent two seasons have only offered diminishing returns as creators Ashley Lyle and Bart Nickerson (Narcos) haven’t been able to extend the potency of their original premise into coherent and compelling past and present narratives walking into Season 4.
As this is the final season, there was plenty of hope that the writing team would pour all of their reserved ideas into purposeful and emotionally rewarding narratives ignited by the plane crash survivors getting rescued from their feral, cannibalistic ways in the Canadian wilderness. Let’s be real: their return to society has long been past due as they’ve killed or eaten two-thirds of the cast. The fourth season premiere episode, “Hivemind,” crackles with the excitement of that anticipated reentry, told through 1998-era TV breaking news announcements, including Gen Z stalwart MTV News. But then Yellowjackets falls back into its bad habits, like leaning on needle drop montages to Nirvana’s “Where Did You Sleep Last Night” to show the broken and battered survivors being examined in the hospital, instead of giving them meaty scenes where they can process the moment with consequential words and deeds.
The present day storyline picks up in the aftermath of Melissa’s (Hilary Swank) murder of Van (Lauren Ambrose). The formerly hidden in plain sight survivor grabs her wife Alex (Jaylee Hamidi) and young daughter to flee the retribution of Tai (Cypress), Shauna (Lynskey) and Misty (Ricci). However, that’s fear wasted because the trio are a rather listless group now. Tai and Misty don’t trust Shauna anymore so they’re quietly plotting, black comedy style, to make their unstable frenemy believably “disappear.”
Season 4 has 10 episodes to land wherever this is going, and so far, the episodes aren’t making a case that this couldn’t have just all wrapped up a season earlier.Shauna has ostracized everyone in her life, including her estranged husband Jeff (Warren Kole) and fellow murderous daughter Callie (Sarah Desjardins). With nothing else to do, she continues to scream at the world, as evidenced by several slightly humorous scenes where Lynskey gives it her all in displaying Shauna’s hair-trigger and unapologetic rage. Unfortunately, surface anger is all the writers are giving Lynskey to play in these early episodes, so there’s no nuance or pathos to make any of it feel scary or even sympathetic. Though it’s clear the writers think Shauna is a punk rock paragon of female retribution, they’re only giving her cartoonish scenarios to express herself, which doesn’t temper the fact that she’s a multi-murderer with deep issues that keep getting kicked down the narrative road – likely to the last episodes of this season.
While two parallel plots have always been plenty for the series — and out of balance interest- wise since the middle of Season 2 — the writers have introduced another side plot to just before the soccer team survivors are rescued. These surprise asides fill in the unknown details between the hunt for Mari (Alexa Barajas) and Nat’s (Sophie Thatcher) success in using the satellite phone in the Season 3 finale. But to be frank, who cares? The past is the past and these extra tidbits don’t move the needle in absolving these kids of the multitude of sins they’ve already agreed to keep to themselves. The show is giving precious story real estate to the minutiae instead of leaning into scenes happening after their New Jersey return, and it’s baffling filler.
Yellowjackets Season 4 has 10 episodes to land wherever this is going, and so far, the episodes aren’t making a case that this couldn’t have just all wrapped up a season earlier. The groundwork is obviously being set for an escalation between an unrepentant Melissa and rage-monster Shauna, with Tai and Misty as cagey observers. Hopefully, that builds into something plausible and worthwhile, because the 1998 reentry story for the survivors is already meandering and so slow that nothing of note is revealed that we don’t already know from prior seasons. It’s filling in gaps and that’s not great television.