TEHRAN– Peter Kuznick, Professor of History and Director of the Nuclear Studies Institute at American University, says the war on Iran carries an unacceptable risk of nuclear escalation.
The arrival of the USS Theodore Roosevelt in the West Asia region has brought the number of U.S. aircraft carriers operating in the region to three, as tensions continue to rise over the U.S.-Israeli war on Iran. Tehran has warned that it would not necessarily wait for Washington to launch another attack before responding. The latest developments come amid mixed signals from the Trump administration. U.S. President Donald Trump has told advisers that he may hold off on further strikes if Iran and Yemen’s Ansarullah do not engage in new provocations. The combination of a reinforced U.S. military presence and uncertainty over Washington’s next move has left the prospects for de-escalation unclear.
Against this backdrop, concerns over the risk of a wider conflict—and its potential nuclear consequences—have taken on renewed urgency. In an interview with Mehr News Agency, American historian and American University professor Peter Kuznick warned that even the possibility of a U.S. or Israeli nuclear strike against Iran represents an unacceptable risk. He stressed that the war could have far-reaching implications beyond the regional military balance, undermining the credibility of the global nuclear non-proliferation regime, exposing the limits of U.S. military power and underscoring the need for a collective security framework in West Asia.
The full text of the interview is as follows,
in your recent writings, you have warned that the war involving Iran, the United States, and Israel could create a serious risk of nuclear escalation. How close do you believe the current confrontation has brought the region and the international community to that threshold? What diplomatic steps could prevent it?
These are the crucial questions. Even a slight chance that the U.S. or Israel could use a nuclear weapon against Iran is an unacceptable risk and must be taken seriously and prevented. Unfortunately, there is more than a slight risk right now. The Republicans’ shellacking in last week’s election could play either way. It could make Trump more desperate and unhinged or it could make him aware of how unpopular this war is and that escalation would be met with universal outrage. That might not be enough to deter a pathological narcissist like Trump, especially when we know there have been discussions in Trump’s circle of using nuclear weapons. Right now, Trump is trying to change the subject and make light of the war. His pulling Vance out of negotiations and having him focus on Democratic “corruption” is emblematic of this messaging. But we all know that Trump can change on a dime and reverse himself. The reports are that he has been in a rage since the humiliating midterm defeat and his pathetically low approval ratings keep shrinking. As I said in the latest Al Jazeera article that Ivana Nikolic Hughes and I wrote, I am certain that historians will rate Trump as the worst president in American history and deservedly so. But what worries me even more at the moment is what Netanyahu and the Israelis might do. To them, an Iranian nuclear program represents an existential threat. Israeli intelligence reports that alleged Iranian nuclear activity seems to be occurring at “PickAxe” Mountain under 300 feet of granite. Neither the U.S. nor Israel has conventional weapons that can penetrate that deep, which is why I fear that they might use one or more nuclear weapons. To make matters worse, more and more Iranians have been saying that in the aftermath of two recent waves of Israeli/U.S. attacks on Iran, Iran needs nuclear weapons to deter further attacks. I understand that logic, but given Trump’s obsession with stopping Iran from acquiring a bomb and Israeli statements about “never again” and a nuclear Iran’s existential threat, it creates a dangerously combustible mix in which any action by the U.S. and Israel is possible. The fact that Trump’s closest advisors—Stephen Miller, Pete Hegseth, Sebastian Gorka, Elbridge Colby, Brad Cooper, Marco Rubio—are all perversely hawkish in their views and the Israel is keep egging Trump on, I worry that such mad behavior is possible.
So far as diplomatic steps, I drafted a letter to Pope Leo XIV urging him to use his unique moral authority as an outspoken opponent of war and proponent of nuclear abolition to call an emergency summit, minimally of Putin, Xi, and Trump, to get us off this path of war and potential nuclear war. That letter is up on the Nuclear Insanity Substack and has been endorsed by close to 250 very influential people around the world as well as hundreds of others. The Pope has joined many experts in warning that talk of nuclear weapons use has been increasing at an alarming rate. Former DNI Tulsi Gabbard warned 18 months ago that we are closer to nuclear annihilation than we have ever been. It’s gotten much, much worse since then. The new piece that Ivana and I have on Al Jazeera calls for Putin, Xi, and Trump to do what Reagan and Gorbachev came so close to achieving at Reykjavik 40 years ago and rid the world of nuclear weapons in three stages over a 12-year period. All three leaders have at time recognized the madness of trying to defend their countries with weapons that will effectively end all large life on our planet if they were ever used. We now know that the threshold for causing nuclear winter is much lower than scientists thought in the 1980s. We also know that the Global South—the BRICS, SCO, African Union, and others—are pushing for a new global order based on peaceful growth and development. So we are trying to rally global forces to pressure the superpowers to find a new direction by ending the Southwest Asia and Ukraine wars and beginning the process of finding peaceful alternatives. It is time to reembrace diplomacy and reject war as a way of resolving differences. But the people of the planet, many of whom still live in poverty and backwardness, must make their voices heard to pressure the “leaders” to reverse course.
Israel's nuclear arsenal and regional security
You have said that the Middle East should become a zone free of weapons of mass destruction. How does Israel's undeclared nuclear arsenal affect the regional balance of power and the security calculations of other countries? Do you believe the international community applies consistent standards to nuclear non-proliferation in the Middle East?
We estimate that Israel has between 90 and 250 nuclear weapons, which it will not relinquish as long as it believes its security is threatened. Despite its longstanding reprehensible and cruel treatment of Palestinians, it was once a respected and admired nation. Now, in the aftermath of its genocide in Gaza and unbridled militarism, it is the most despised country in the world. The more isolated Israel has become, the more it has moved to the right. It has long been governed by far-right extremists who are adamantly opposed to both a one-state and a two-state solution. U.S. support for Israel was a big issue in the U.S. midterms. The Biden-Harris administration’s support for the Gaza slaughter had been a major issue in Trump’s 2024 election. Trump has proven to be even worse than Biden. But the American people have seen enough and AIPAC support for candidates was more of a detriment than a help in the midterms. Without undeviating U.S. support, financially, militarily, and diplomatically, Israel will likely find itself even more isolated. But not only will U.S. support for Israel slide, the overall U.S. role in the region will also change as its bases and alliances have come under attack. The largely corrupt [Persian] Gulf leaders, who have long assumed they benefitted from U.S. protection are being forced to reconsider whether housing U.S. military bases and tying themselves to the U.S. gives them greater security or it makes them bigger targets. Also much of the U.S. military infrastructure has been destroyed and will cost many billions of dollars to replace. So the Israelis will have to make a choice—either live in perpetual hostility to their neighbors or learn to live together peacefully. If the former, they will retain their nuclear arsenal and hide behind it. If the latter, after years of trust-building, they can rethink their dependence on nuclear weapons.
Israel is one of four nuclear powers and five countries in total that are outside the NPT, but it is the only country outside the NPT in what used to be called the “Middle East.” Its official stance on possessing nuclear weapons is ambiguity, but everyone knows it has had them for decades. Western powers, led by the U.S., have shielded Israel from greater scrutiny and sanctions. So, yes, there is a clear double standard where Israel’s interests and nuclear policy are concerned.
Iran, which is a party to the NPT and had allowed IAEA monitoring until the June bombing of its nuclear facilities, has been hit with severe sanctions as well as bombings and assassinations for enriching uranium, despite the fact that it is permitted to do so under the NPT. Such double standards and hypocrisy have not gone unnoticed in much of the world.
The historical pattern of U.S. military interventions
Drawing on your research into the history of American foreign policy, what historical patterns do you see in Washington's decision to enter the current confrontation with Iran? To what extent does this war reflect the recurring assumption that military superiority can produce political outcomes, despite the experiences of previous U.S. interventions?
The U.S. has long viewed Southwest Asia as crucial to U.S. national security and has happily climbed into bed with reactionary dictators who allowed the U.S. to exploit the region’s oil resources. It has been willing to use force where necessary to keep these leaders in power and to block more progressive leaders from challenging them. Perhaps the most egregious case is what the CIA did to Iran in 1953 when it overthrew Mohammad Mossadeq, despite the fact that he was enormously popular both inside and outside Iran. He had been Time Magazine man of the year in 1951 and the U.S. ambassador said he had the support of between 95 and 98 percent of the Iranian people. But he committed the cardinal sin—thinking the Iranian people and not the British oil companies had a right to the proceeds from selling Iranian oil. When Iran nationalized the oil industry, the CIA overthrew Mossadeq and installed the Shah, who ruled with an iron fist and brutal SAVAK until 1979. This made a mockery of U.S. claims to support democracy. U.S. oil companies soon had 40 percent of the Iranian market. So the overthrow of the repressive and despised Shah, whom Jimmy Carter proclaimed his dear friend, declaring at the infamous New Year’s Eve dinner, “There is no leader with whom I have a deeper sense of personal gratitude and personal friendship,” should not have come as a big surprise. The U.S. has maintained its hostile stance toward Iran ever since, although there were times, such as in the 1980s during what became known here as the “Iran-Contra Scandal,” when it was willing to sell Iran arms to procure cash for its Central American war criminal allies.