Vijay Maharaj and Dr Raj Govender.

A Tamil Business Warriors (TBW) member claims he has not received annual financial statements and is questioning the organisation’s governance.

The CEO disputes some claims and says a virtual AGM is being planned.

KZN businessman Vijay Maharaj, raised his concerns in a series of messages circulated on the organisation's members-only WhatsApp group.

He claimed that members had not been given access to annual financial statements for the past nine years.

Maharaj also questioned the alleged lack of annual general meetings (AGMs), financial reporting and clarity on how membership fees, sponsorships and donations were being utilised.

He told sundaytribune.co.za that he stood by the contents of his messages, which he had posted on the TBW members-only group chat.

Maharaj also confirmed that the response to his message was from CEO Dr Rajendran Govender.

The messages were subsequently leaked to the media.

Maharaj said he had been a member of TBW for approximately five years and had enjoyed the networking opportunities, camaraderie and business relationships he had developed through the organisation.

"In fact, it brought value to me personally and professionally. I was able to connect with fellow shareholders, build relationships and even explore business opportunities with some of them," he said.

He said he had remained an active, paid-up member, attending events including gala dinners and business forums, and had travelled to Mauritius three times to support the organisation's functions.

However, he said concerns about governance and accountability prompted him to question whether members were being given sufficient information about the organisation's financial affairs.

Maharaj said that, despite his involvement, he was unaware of an AGM having been held or annual financial statements having been presented to members during his association with the organisation.

"Yet, in the approximately five years that I have been associated with TBW, I am not aware of a single AGM having been held or a set of Annual Financial Statements having been presented to members," he claimed.

He added that he had approached the organisation's founder, co-founder, chief executive officer and chapter heads on numerous occasions seeking the information but had not received the requested documents.

"To my knowledge, members have not been presented with the financial statements for the past nine years," he said.

Maharaj said his concerns were not limited to the availability of financial statements but also extended to how funds raised through membership fees, sponsorships, donations and events were being spent.

He questioned whether the organisation was investing in meaningful programmes and business development initiatives to empower its members, beyond hosting networking functions and gala dinners.

"An organisation of this nature should not only provide a platform for networking but should also demonstrate tangible outcomes in the empowerment and advancement of its members," he said.

He also detailed his attempts to obtain the financial statements following TBW's most recent gala dinner.

According to Maharaj, TBW founder Karthi Moothsamy told attendees during his address that all paid-up members could obtain the financial statements from Jennifer at Morar Incorporated.

Maharaj said he subsequently approached Jennifer at the event and followed up with an email after returning to his office.

However, he claimed she had directed him to contact CEO Dr Rajendran Govender instead.

Maharaj said he emailed Govender, copying Jennifer into the correspondence, but received no response.

He later sent WhatsApp reminders and was asked to resend the email.

He said that, despite further follow-ups, the financial statements remained outstanding.

"To date, I have still not received the requested financial statements or any meaningful feedback explaining the delay," he said.

CEO responds

Responding on the same platform, Govender said TBW had taken note of Maharaj's comments but disputed some of the claims.

"While the message contains several inaccuracies and assumptions, we do not believe it is necessary or productive to respond to each of these in detail on this platform. However, it is important to place certain facts on record," Govender said.

He said it was factually incorrect to suggest that TBW had never held an AGM, explaining that a virtual meeting had previously been convened.

Govender said the initial meeting could not proceed because a quorum was not reached and was subsequently rescheduled.

"The primary purpose of that AGM was to consider and approve the organisation's Memorandum of Incorporation (MOI)," he said.

He added that management was currently planning the next AGM, during which audited financial statements would be presented to members.

"The necessary arrangements will be communicated to members in due course," he said.

Govender said the meeting would be held virtually because TBW had members across different provinces in South Africa, as well as internationally, and the format would allow for broader participation.

He reaffirmed the organisation's commitment to good governance, accountability, transparency and its objectives, adding that concerns about governance were best addressed through the appropriate structures and processes.

However, Maharaj responded to Govender's message, saying the explanation about a previously held virtual AGM did not address the wider issues he had raised.

He questioned what had happened to the AGMs in the subsequent years and reiterated his demand for the outstanding financial statements.

"Surely, the mention of one virtual AGM does not address the broader concerns I raised," he said.

Maharaj added that he was disappointed that Govender's response had focused largely on whether an AGM had previously taken place, rather than addressing the other concerns raised in his original message.

He also questioned whether the proposed AGM should be exclusively virtual, suggesting that an in-person meeting could be held in Durban, with members from other provinces and overseas participating online.

"Durban has a considerable number of TBW members, and I am sure that we could achieve a quorum for an in-person meeting in Durban, with members from other provinces and internationally joining virtually," he said.

Maharaj maintained that his intention was not to create conflict or make the matter personal, but to ensure that members' questions about the organisation's governance were addressed.

"My intention remains unchanged. I am not looking for confrontation or making this personal. I am asking for what I believe every member should be entitled to ask," he said.

He called on the organisation to make the outstanding annual financial statements available to all paid-up members and clarify when the last AGM was held and when the next meeting would take place.

He warned that, should members not be entitled to request or access the information, he would reconsider his membership and withdraw from the organisation.

"I would rather retract my request, reconsider my membership and withdraw from the group than remain associated with an organisation where legitimate questions about transparency and accountability cannot be addressed.

"I am not looking for confrontation, nor am I questioning anyone's personal integrity. I am asking for transparency, accountability and the basic governance processes that members should reasonably expect,” said Maharaj. 

The Tamil Business Warriors was approached for further comment but did not respond at the time of publication.