Chief of Defence Intelligence, Matthew Jones speech at Cambridge Intelligence Seminar.
Good afternoon and it is both a great privilege and pleasure to return to Corpus Christi College and speak at the Cambridge Intelligence Seminar. I have been an admirer of the seminar for many years and am grateful for you giving me the opportunity to address you on contemporary issues, conscious that your normal focus is understandably on the past. I am also pleased that there are members of Corpus’ newly formed Security and Risk Society here this afternoon, and look forward to meeting you afterwards. I wonder if some of you might be the next generation of national security professionals.
I am particularly thankful to Professor Chris Andrew as the convener. Thirty years after you supervised me in intelligence history here at Corpus, I hope I can demonstrate I did pay attention to you at least occasionally. You of course remain one of the world’s pre-eminent intelligence historians, and your impact on this historical discipline and on the intelligence community has been profound.
Your most famous collaboration was of course with Oleg Gordievsky, the KGB rezident in London who worked as an agent for MI6 and was exfiltrated out of the Soviet Union in 1985. My favourite tale is how, as part of Operation RYAN in the early 1980s, Gordievsky and his colleagues were responsible for counting how many lights remained on late in the evening at the Ministry of Defence’s Main Building in Whitehall. This was based on the theory that the more lights were left on, the more likely it was that senior officers and officials were planning a strike on the Soviet Union.
Now, from my intelligence training, I am not sure that was ever a particularly good indicator or warning of British military intentions in the early 1980s, and it certainly isn’t now… However, as I now find myself often working late into the evening in MOD Main Building, I cannot help see some similarities with that era. None of us want war, but we must both remain watchful and vigilant for that eventuality and must do all we can to prevent it.
There is a real contrast between the view of peaceful everyday London when I look out of my window down the Thames, and the concerning papers I read at my desk.
The threats are manifest whether that be the ongoing war in Ukraine; the wider risk of escalation in Europe; the arc of conflict across the Horn of Africa, Arabian Peninsula, and Middle East; the mind-boggling scale and pace of the military capability build-up in East Asia; the exponential rise in AI driven offensive cyber-attacks; or the seemingly daily reality of sub-threshold adversary operations impacting the UK and our allies. The global security environment is definitely deteriorating.
That is why Defence Intelligence – DI - and the wider Military Intelligence Services are so important to protecting the country today. In an era of volatility, uncertainty, technological and climate change, and heightened threats, it is more important than ever that the MOD and the nation has the ability to understand and respond to the challenges. Since July, I have been proud to lead this organisation of nearly 4000 tri-service and civil service specialists.
The range of expertise we have within the team never ceases to amaze me: We have national experts at cutting edge military capabilities, talented linguists in a range of interesting languages, skilled geospatial imagery analysts, cunning and brave agent handlers, determined counter intelligence investigators, and ingenious data scientists. I could keep going but the key of course is working collaboratively to ensure the sum of the DI whole is much greater than the individual efforts of the team. An inclusive and collegiate approach is at the core of everything we do. Something Robert Pattinson could only ever dream of emulating!
And, although he was not serving in DI at the time of his death, it is appropriate to remember Major Paul Wilks of the Army Intelligence Corps who was tragically killed in a road collision in Ukraine in September. Paul served for many years within DI and was a highly talented and committed officer who had huge operational impact.
DI has three missions. The first is to deliver on operations today. Wherever members of the UK armed forces are deployed, members of DI are alongside them. In eastern Europe, the Middle East, and with partners in a range of fascinating locations, as well as at all our overseas bases. And at our intelligence centre at Wyton, not too far away from where we are gathered now, there are teams working 24/7 to monitor threats and coordinate Defence’s intelligence response to emerging crises.
We also work closely with partners in the UK, and the recent threats at RAF Fairford and last week’s arrest of an officer assigned to the NATO Allied Rapid Reaction Corps demonstrate we need to respond to challenges at home as well as overseas. Developing our approach to homeland and national defence is one of my top priorities, and DI is working with the Standing Joint Command and a range of partner organisations to ensure our people and bases are protected.
The second mission is to conduct vigilant deterrence. As Mr. Streeting, the Secretary of State for Defence, himself of course also a Cambridge historian, said in Oslo last week, the more ready we are to fight and win, the less likely war becomes.
DI’s mission as part of the deterrence effort is to provide vigilance. Working with partners, we gain insight into adversary capabilities and developments, and their intent to use those against us. We cannot predict the future, but we can provide foresight to reduce uncertainty. In a murky world of cyber-attacks, drone incursions which may or may not be an accident and, as last weekend’s attempted attack in Estonia showed, increasing sabotage, DI’s role is to find the signal in the noise.
War-fighting readiness cannot only be achieved through boosting conventional forces, it must also be done by staying at the cutting edge in the intelligence world. More equipment which glistens in the sun, but also highly advanced operators and intelligence capabilities are active in the shadows.
Our third mission is to prepare for war. Alongside our maritime, land, air, cyber, and space forces, DI needs to be ready to fight in the Sixth-Generation Battlespace. This means playing our part in being ready to find, fix, track, and target our adversaries. In DI we are at the forefront of transforming Defence’s targeting efforts.
The Digital Targeting Web is the underpinning capability of the SDR and Defence Investment Plan, and DI is already benefiting from the resources that are flowing from that. Our aim is to help connect an array of sensors with the armed forces’ weapons systems with a ‘single pane of glass’, a common intelligence picture providing clarity on an ever-foggier battlefield.
We also need to play our role protecting the armed forces from attacks and deception. The money allocated to the Targeting Web in the SDR is already having an impact and enabling us to improve collaboration with our allies and partners. Later this month the Cyber and Specialist Operations Command, of which DI is a part, will bring into operation a new sensitive capability that will greatly enhance our ability to acquire targets and provide more precise data to frontline forces – this represents a key stepping stone to equip our forces for the modern battlefield.
It will not surprise you we are spending a lot of time looking at how the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East are being fought, taking advantages of those lessons, and helping to ensure the UK could fight and win in this environment if required. Warfare is being transformed seemingly daily through the combination of artificial intelligence and uncrewed systems, and DI is helping our Armed Forces adapt to the opportunities and challenges this poses.
We achieve these missions by enabling effective decisions, protecting the force and the nation, driving targeting, and executing a range of overt and covert effects. We do all this in a legal and policy compliant manner, and I welcome the robust oversight of Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee.
You will appreciate there are limits in what I can say in an open seminar, but I would like to give a flavour of our activities.
Enabling effective decisions sounds straightforward but is vital to effective military strategy and operations. Just as in life, all of us weigh up options constantly and make choices based on varying sources of sometimes conflicting data, so we must in Defence too. Within DI, we cannot predict the future but can reduce the uncertainty, to enable the best choices, often in time pressurised and constrained situations:
This gives a flavour of the types of questions we in DI are routinely called upon to answer.
We do this by fusing together a range of sources from the most sensitive intelligence to openly accessible information. At the core of this work is the judgment of highly trained and skilled analysts operating across a range of high-tech systems, providing assessment in an objective and dispassionate manner. The so-called Butler principles, established in the wake of the 2003 Iraq War, underpin our work and I am constantly proud to see junior colleagues having the moral courage to speak truth to power, and senior colleagues being ready to listen and accept this. Unlike our adversaries, we will never skew our assessments to satisfy a pre-conceived decision.
As a much younger officer I learned the importance of intelligence to force protection as Task Force Helmand’s Brigade Intelligence Officer in southern Afghanistan. My team and I were constantly seeking to ensure we had the best intelligence picture possible of where the Taleban were laying IEDs, preparing ambushes, or planning mortar and missile attacks. And once we had that intelligence, it was critical to ensure it got to the frontline in time for the battle groups to act to avoid and neutralise those threats.
Today the adversary and geography might be different, but the intelligence force protection mission remains vital. Whenever a British warship, aircraft, or Army unit heads into harm’s way, we play our role in ensuring it is prepared and protected. Whether this is a Royal Fleet Auxiliary ship in the Arabian Sea, an RAF Rivet Joint reconnaissance plane heading towards the High North, or the Army battle group in Estonia, we take this duty incredibly seriously.
And we also ensure the whole of Defence is protected from hostile intelligence and espionage. The arrest in Gloucestershire earlier this month demonstrates this threat is very real. We can never be complacent as we know our enemies are actively seeking to steal our secrets.
However, the formation of the Defence Counter Intelligence Unit – the DCIU - earlier this year, delivering an SDR commitment, marked a considerable step forward. The DCIU is already proving its worth both at home and overseas. Defence Counter Intelligence, working alongside many partners, played a considerable role in that arrest of the US service person. Like our conventional forces, this shows how Defence Intelligence is at the front line of tackling and deterring threats.
We also execute a range of effects in conjunction with partner organisations. Most of these are covert and need to stay in the shadows for reasons I am sure you understand, but I look forward to future historians combing the archives to discover the feats we were up to. I am sure it will be a topic ripe for consideration at this Seminar during the Michaelmas term of 2056. I look forward to being invited back to participate.