Secretary of State for Scotland addressed the COSLA annual conference in St Andrews on 19 November 2006.

The Rt Hon Douglas Alexander MP

And thank you to Fife Council for welcoming us to the Kingdom.

First, as the son, and the grandson, of Church of Scotland ministers, I hope you’ll forgive me for starting with an archbishop. A pre-Reformation one at that.

Back in 1552, Archbishop Hamilton’s charter confirmed the right of the ordinary people of St Andrews to play on the links. 

Not a favour handed down, but a right that belonged to the whole community. 

And to this day, the Old Course is a public course.

This town has always understood something about local power. Bringing some of Scotland’s earliest acts of community empowerment, I would suggest.

So it’s a fitting and a good place to start today.

And St Andrews has also seen what can happen when people come together around a table.

Twenty years ago last month, in this very hotel, talks between the British and Irish governments and Northern Ireland’s parties produced what became known as the St Andrew’s Agreement.

It paved the way for devolved, power-sharing government to return to Northern Ireland.

Now, those talks took place, of course, in circumstances far different – and, frankly, far  harder – than anything we experience today in Scotland.

I would suggest they left a simple message.

When people put the public they serve first, rather than party politics, agreement, even in unlikely circumstances, can be possible.

Hold on to that thought, because I want to return to it in the course of my remarks.

But before I go any further, let me offer a sincere and heartfelt thank you to all of you – the council leaders, councillors and officers gathered in this room - for the work you do each and every week, each and every month, for the communities the length and breadth of our nation.

Your services touch the lives of every resident and every community. And too often over recent years, you’re the last line of defence for them.

Nowhere is that clearer than housing. Fourteen of Scotland’s councils now, including Fife, Dundee, and my own East Lothian, have declared housing emergencies. 

And more than ten thousand children across Scotland are living in temporary accommodation, the highest ever recorded number.

When a family has nowhere to go, I know it’s your staff who pick up the phone and work to find them a place to lay their head at the night.

So thank you. Thank you for the work you do. Thank you for the service that you give and thank you for the difference that you make.

Now, this year’s theme is ‘Local Leadership in a Changing World.’ 

Because, of course, the world is changing fast. And the question is whether local leaders are given the power to shape that change, or simply left to manage the consequences of change.

And it’s a theme, I would suggest, with real urgency.

Local leadership is changing, and next May, people in every part of Scotland will choose their councils. 

Whoever they choose deserves to inherit not just the responsibility, but the power and the funding to make a difference.

So today, from this platform, I want to set out the UK Government’s thinking about regional empowerment, and why I believe it offers a way forward for Scotland’s communities.

Exactly, a year ago, on this platform, I said two things that I felt then, and that I still feel now.

First, that local government has been systematically deprioritised in its funding during the era of devolution.

And secondly, that it has watched power pulled up to Holyrood, rather than passed down to communities and councils across the country.

I want to be honest today about where we, as a nation, still find ourselves today.

But I also want to tell you why I’ve rarely been more optimistic about where we could gather and go next.

First, numbers. Not an opinion, not a claim. Simply numbers. 

Since 2013, the block grant from Westminster has grown by more than twenty per cent in real terms.

But council funding? Just five per cent.

If council funding had simply kept pace, Scotland’s councils would have around £2 billion more to spend each and every year. 

That’s two billion pounds that could be paying for schools, social care, for roads and for housing.

Per person, council funding has risen by just £35 in real terms over twelve years.

That’s not even the price of a coffee in some shops these days. For a year of the services on which all of us rely.

And just this month, I know COSLA launched its budget campaign, warning, and I quote directly, there’s “little left to cut without communities feeling the impact.” 

Councils deliver the services, as you know better than anyone, on which all of us rely on every single day. Educating our children. Caring for people in their own homes. Fixing the roads, Tackling homeless. Standing by and with vulnerable families. 

And frankly, our communities deserve better.

The Finance Secretary sets out her Budget next month. 

Listen to the people gathered in this room.

Because here in Scotland, while money has been squeezed out, the power has been pulled in. 

Police and fire run as single national bodies. Council tax is set all too often from the top. Ring-fence after ring-fence. 

But councils aren’t and shouldn’t be branch offices of St Andrew’s House.

Too often councils have been handed the bill, and then handed the blame.

After nineteen years in government, the Scottish Government can try, as they always do, to keep pointing the finger at Westminster. 

But let me be clear that the £2 billion gap isn’t Westminster’s choice. It’s the SNP’s. 

For nineteen years, the motto has been “Holyrood knows best”.

Because Holyrood doesn’t know best about Dundee. Dundee does.

Scotland deserves better than the Scottish Government forever demanding power from London and then hoarding it from communities across the country.

So let’s just start just across the Tay. Dundee is a UNESCO City of Design. It gave the world Grand Theft Auto, as we’re all reading about in our phones today. And it has the V&A on its waterfront. 

Real talent. Real ambition, real possibilities.

Yet the council has had to consult on ending its support for the Rep and Dundee Contemporary Arts.

When a City of Design has to think about cutting its own culture, something has gone badly wrong.

And this summer, when it hosted the Commonwealth Games, the whole world saw what Glasgow can still achieve. 

Yet walk along Sauchiehall Street and look at the state it’s in. Go down to Central Station and you’ll see the gap where Union Corner stood for 175 years. Go down to the bottom of Buchanan Street and look at St Enoch Square.

This is a city has been short-changed by £357 million. 

Glasgow used to be miles better. But frankly now it risks being miles behind.

And it’s why those in Dundee, those in Glasgow, and so many of you right across the country have been calling for real powers to be pushed out of Holyrood.

You shouldn’t have to wait, I would suggest, on Holyrood’s permission. 

From Dundee to Glasgow, it’s the same story. 

So today, I want to suggest a way forward.

I know there are ongoing conversations about local government reform and, of course, they matter.

The future of local government is rightly a matter for you and for the Scottish Government to work through together.

But, let’s be honest with each other, reform is a long road, and it can’t hold us back.

Every generation of Scots has had to wrestle with the same question. Not “who are we?” – we’ve never had much trouble answering that question. But “who decides?”.

Who decides whether the steelworks stays open. Whether the bus still runs to the village. Whether the young person in the scheme gets a second chance.

Next year marks thirty years since Scotland gave its answer, and voted for a parliament of its own. 

Donald Dewar, the late, great First Minister of Scotland, said this - devolution was “not an end” but “a means to greater ends.”

Thirty years on, the question, therefore, is no longer whether power should be devolved, but how far it should travel.

Because devolution was never meant to stop at the doors of Holyrood.

Power was meant to keep moving. From London to Edinburgh, yes, and on, and on. To every town, city and region in this country. 

The test was never where the parliament sits. It’s whether a family in Wick or Wishaw, in Dumfries or Dundee, feels more control over their circumstances and of their own life.

And in a changing world, the challenges we face here are the same ones facing every other part of the United Kingdom.

Low growth. Productivity has barely moved since the financial crisis, and seven of the twenty least productive large cities in the G7 are here in the United Kingdom.

And a government that’s amongst the most centralised in the democratic world, too often out of touch with the places that they serve.

Regional empowerment, I want to suggest, answers each of those challenges. 

Reindustrialisation and good growth in every postcode. Services built around local people, with decisions made by those who know their areas best.

And that, of course, includes you. The people in this room are the leaders who need the powers and the funding to deliver real change in every part of Scotland. 

But here’s the part a lot of people don’t know…

Part of what Andy Burnham achieved in Greater Manchester was actually made in Scotland.

There’s a book the Prime Minister says shaped his thinking - Darren McGarvey’s Poverty Safari.

And I sat down with Darren a few weeks ago. 

He grew up just outside Glasgow in Pollok, and his argument is that too many services are designed for struggling communities, rather than with those communities.

In 2023, as Greater Manchester Mayor, Andy visited a community project in Easterhouse. Staff there built a personal pathway into work for every young person, even covering the cost of clothes and the bus fare to get to the interviews.

He took the idea home to Manchester and it shaped the Live Well approach right across Greater Manchester, that he then implemented.

Andy calls it the Easterhouse principle. Names, not just numbers.

An idea born in Easterhouse had to emigrate to be taken seriously.

But now we have the chance to bring that idea home.

And that’s why, as I stand here today, I’m so optimistic.

When the Prime Minister came to Motherwell last month, he made a sincere and genuine offer. 

To move on from the old politics of conflict. And to design a new model - together - of regional economic empowerment all across Scotland.

He called it a politics that puts place first, not party first. 

And at the National Economic Council in Glasgow, the First Minister said yes. 

So remember the lesson of St Andrews. If agreement could be found here, in far different and far more difficult circumstances, then surely we can find a way to share power with Scotland’s communities.

Of course we will go on disagreeing about constitutional matters such as independence. That’s democracy. But it’s no barrier to working together on what matters to families from Easterhouse to Peterhead.

No10 North is already facilitating a policy sprint with officials from both governments. 

It’s deliberately led by officials, to keep focus on finding common ground and to take the performative politics out of the process.

And we want to draw on the expertise of Scotland’s regions.

I welcome the ambition already set out by Glasgow City Region, by Edinburgh and South East Scotland, and by others.

And let me be clear. I don’t want to see this done to communities. I want to see it be done with them.

As the Prime Minister has said, growth cannot be ordered from the top down. It has to be built from the bottom up.

So, alongside the policy sprint that’s been initiated, before the end of the year, I will hold a series of regional empowerment roundtables with businesses, communities and those people who know these places best.

The UK Government is prepared to put real responsibilities on the table. Powers like employment support and innovation funding, reflecting that Easterhouse principle.