Is love selfish?
Source Express Tribune 巴基斯坦论坛快报15h ago
Summary
A charming romance masking a heavy reckoning with bodily decline, love’s limits and assisted dying
Full Text
When Me Before You arrived in cinemas in the summer of 2016, I dismissed it at a glance. The pairing of Game of Thrones star Emilia Clarke being ‘cute’ wearing colourful tights and toothy saccharine grin opposite The Hunger Games alum Sam Claflin was not enough to make it stand out. The film looked like every other sappy rom-com from that era (complete with Ed Sheeran on soundtrack). The plot appeared formulaic enough: a quirky, working-class optimist melts the icy exterior of a brooding, wealthy and handsome cynic. It went immediately to my “skip it” list.
Watching the film years after its initial release, and with previous judgments forgotten, it turned out to be a far more sobering and complicated piece of storytelling than I had expected. Adapted by British author Jojo Moyes from her 2012 bestselling novel and directed by acclaimed theatre veteran Thea Sharrock, the movie successfully masquerades as a conventional fairytale while tackling an issue that is as serious as it gets. Beneath its warm aesthetic and charming banter lies a startling confrontation with the limits of romantic love in the face of debilitating bodily decline, and the deeply controversial ethics of assisted dying.
Me Before You catches unprepared viewers off guard because it does not set the tone for its ending. Sharrock and Moyes deliberately yet delicately subvert the classic romance template– most likely for the ease of commercial success. The premise is a pure storybook setup where Louisa "Lou" Clark (Clarke), an eccentric, perpetually cheerful twenty-something living in a picturesque English town, loses her job at a local café and desperately needs income to support her financially struggling family. She takes a well-paying six-month position as a companion and caregiver to quadriplegic Will Traynor (Claflin) who lives in a castle. After being struck by a motorcycle two years ago, Will is as different as he can be from the person he was before –a jet-setting, adrenaline-junkie London banker.
At first, the narrative hits every familiar beat of the genre. Will is disabled and for that reason he is bitter, sarcastic, and withdrawn, hiding behind a wall of disdain. You may well yawn reading what’s coming next because that is how predictable it is on paper: Lou is gregarious, dressed in clashing vintage outfits, determined to crack his shell with her sunny attitude.
Filmed largely at Pembroke Castle in Wales and Chenies Manor House in Buckinghamshire—the visuals lean heavily into a postcard-pretty England aesthetic set against the imposing backdrop of a grand country estate. As Lou slowly chips away at Will’s hostility through banter, and small outings, the audience automatically begins to expect the standard cinematic resolution: love will heal all wounds. Will will rediscover his zest for life, and the two will walk—or roll—off into a sunset happily-ever-after.
However, things steadily become serious as Will’s health takes a turn for the worse. Midway through the story, Lou discovers the real reason Will’s mother hired her for a strict six-month term: Will has already made arrangements to travel to Dignitas, an assisted-suicide clinic in Switzerland, to end his life. He promised his parents six months to give them time to accept his decision. Lou’s real job, unbeknownst to her, is to convince him to stay alive beyond this deadline.
Once that truth surfaces, Me Before You stops being a cutesy romance and becomes an uncomfortable philosophical inquiry. In almost every mainstream love story, devotion is presented as a force capable of conquering all– from classism to grief, trauma, and despair. Moyes’ screenplay does not offer that comfort. Lou throws herself into a desperate campaign to prove to Will that his life still holds the capacity for joy and to be loved by her. She organises a bucket list of experiences for him to enjoy under the pretext of helping him live his short life to the fullest. Somewhere along the excursions to horse races, classical concerts, a wedding, and finally an exotic beach vacation, she has the hope that her quadriplegic lover will change his mind about the death he has signed up for.
The tragedy—and the surprise for anyone expecting a crowd-pleaser—is that Lou succeeds in making Will fall in love with her, yet she fails to change his mind. During a devastating conversation on the beach in Mauritius, Will tells Lou that their time together has been the best part of his life since his accident, but he still refuses to live on in a body that causes him constant physical pain and total loss of independence. He also argues that staying alive would tether Lou to a diminished existence as his caretaker rather than allowing her to explore the world and realise her dreams. Predictably, being a woman, Lou has faith in her unconditional love and is heartbroken by his selfish, unilateral decision.
Whether one agrees with Will’s reasoning or finds it deeply flawed, the narrative courage required to deny a mainstream studio audience its happy ending is thought-provoking. The film forces viewers to sit with an agonizing question: if two people genuinely love each other, is that bond sufficient reason for one of them to endure a life they no longer wish to live? By refusing to blink at the end—following Lou to Switzerland for their final goodbye with Will’s parents also present—the movie transforms from an easy watch into a lingering meditation on agency and trauma. The parents bow to their son’s will and the viewers can only wonder how any parent would survive such a predicament in real life. For Lou, the filmmakers open up a possibility of a better future and the residual bitter-sweet strength of her relationship with Will.
A premise this volatile could easily collapse into melodrama, but it is largely the restraint of Thea Sharrock’s direction that keep the film grounded. Making her debut feature film, Sharrock treats the material with quiet theatrical intimacy. Rather than relying on sweeping orchestral swells or overly stylized camera tricks, she lets scenes breathe through close-ups and stillness. The shifting power dynamics between Lou and Will register in small glances and pauses. Visually, Sharrock consciously moves the palette from the muted, overcast greys of rural England to brighter, expansive horizons as Will ventures back into the world, mirroring his emotional thawing– and this too is done subtly.
Best known globally at the time for playing Daenerys Targaryen in GoT, Clarke pivots effortlessly into physical comedy. Her hyper-expressive face could have been irritating and tipped Lou into caricature, yet somehow working-class frankness appears as genuine warmth. When Lou’s cheerfulness finally breaks under the weight of Will’s decision, Clarke’s grief feels unvarnished and raw.
Opposite her, Claflin spent months researching spinal cord injuries and working alongside medical consultants to deliver a performance that entailed acting almost entirely from the neck up. Claflin conveys the exhaustion and frustration of quadriplegia. His chemistry with Clarke is built on sharp comedic timing that makes their eventual heartbreak sting all the harder. Meanwhile, veteran British actors Charles Dance and Janet McTeer bring gravitas as Will’s parents. Both stand on either side of the fate their son has chosen. The mother is trapped between her desperation to keep her son alive and her hope that he will change his mind and the father maintaining agonizing respect for his son’s autonomy bearing his pain in mind.
Despite its box-office triumph, Me Before You sustained backlash from the disability community. Upon the film’s release, disability rights advocates and activists—including groups such as Not Dead Yet UK—protested at premieres and launched viral campaigns under hashtags like #MeBeforeEuthanasia and #MeBeforeAbleism. Their critique struck at the core ethical tension of both Moyes’ novel and Sharrock’s adaptation.
Critics argued that by framing Will’s suicide as an act of noble self-sacrifice—one that conveniently frees Lou from caregiving duties and provides her with a substantial inheritance to fund her dreams in Paris—the story perpetuates the dangerous ableist trope that life with a severe disability is inherently tragic, burdensome, and "worse than death". Several disabled writers and wheelchair users pointed out a glaring contradiction in the narrative: Will possesses immense generational wealth, a loving family, a devoted partner, and access to round-the-clock private medical care—resources most disabled people can only dream of—yet the story still insists his life is unlivable and positions assisted dying as a noble gift that frees the able-bodied protagonist to "live boldly."
Furthermore, activists criticised the filmmakers for glossing over the daily realities of living with quadriplegia in favour of a sanitised, romantic tragedy–in my opinion again this was a device employed to make the film more watchable. In interviews, Sharrock noted that she deliberately avoided showing Will being hoisted out of bed or struggling with physical care routines so as not to make audiences uncomfortable and to "normalise" his presence. To disabled viewers, however, editing out the practical realities of adaptive living—or Will receiving meaningful psychological counseling—stacked the narrative deck in favour of his death.
Disablity rights activists also pointed to a double standard in how suicidal ideation is treated. When non-disabled people express a wish to die, society generally responds with intervention and suicide prevention, whereas Will’s desire to end his life is framed as personal autonomy—omitting the portrayal of disabled characters who might reflect a fuller spectrum of lived experience. Weighing those critiques makes the romance feel less like simple comfort viewing and more like a story asking who gets to define a life worth living
Looking at Me Before You with clear eyes requires holding two truths at once. As a piece of filmmaking, it is smartly handled and more restrained despite an emotionally devastating story arc. At the same time, it exposes a blind spot in how mainstream cinema approaches bodily autonomy and disability. Nonetheless, the film succeeds at asking whether love is enough to keep someone alive or turn away love that promises to remain by one’s side in sickness and in health.
Full text provided by the source Express Tribune 巴基斯坦论坛快报 via RSS; copyright belongs to the original publisher.
We index headlines and summaries only. Full content and copyright remain with the original publisher — follow the source link to read it.
Open original- Desk
- World
- Region
- India
- Language
- English
- Item ID
- world-5c4c097d
Comments 0 comments
No comments yet. Be the first.