Kate Box plays Jenny Miller, a mother determined to help her son Rhys (Jack Patten) who has been traumatised by wrongful claims he owes Centrelink money. Photograph: ABC/Lisa TomasettiView image in fullscreenKate Box plays Jenny Miller, a mother determined to help her son Rhys (Jack Patten) who has been traumatised by wrongful claims he owes Centrelink money. Photograph: ABC/Lisa Tomasetti

There’s an important story to be told here, but this four-part drama starring Justine Clarke, Kate Box and Mandy McElhinney is clumsily staged with some comically laboured dialogue

Get our weekend culture and lifestyle email

Australia’s robodebt scandal remains a barely believable fiasco in which the government not only failed to look after people but actively plotted against them, resulting in unthinkable suffering and tragedy. It stands as a stain on the national consciousness and a shameful part of the legacies of Scott Morrison, then social services minister, and Tony Abbott, then prime minister – an example of leadership at its cruellest and most callous.

As the country continues to make sense of how this happened, and the devastating toll it reaped, it stands to reason that the subject would find its way into drama. Enter Shakedown, a four-part series directed by Jennifer Leacey, who’s worked on some impressive productions (among them Fake, Prosper and The Messenger). But sadly this is not one of them: the series is clumsily staged and populated by thinly drawn characters, portrayed by a cast burdened with bland and sometimes terribly on-the-nose dialogue.

Principal characters include Justine Clarke’s dignified public servant Colleen Taylor, a Centrelink compliance officer aghast at the government’s decisions and determined to do the right thing within a fundamentally unjust program. In a villain-adjacent space, Mandy McElhinney delivers the show’s most intriguing performance as Malisa Golightly, deputy secretary of the human services department, who played a significant role in pushing the scheme through – portrayed less as a baddie per se than a toxic leader.

2.6 Seconds: Death in the Outback review – this docuseries about an Australian tragedy is shockingly intenseRead more

On the receiving end of the system is Kate Box’s Jenny Miller, a mother determined to help her son Rhys Cauzzo (Jack Patten), who struggles with his mental health and is traumatised by erroneous claims that he owes the department an enormous amount of money. Victoria Haralabidou’s Sandra Bevan, a widowed single parent, is among those also unfairly targeted, deciding to take her case to the tribunal. There are many others, but as the show’s time and location-shifting structure regularly jumps around a large cast, it creates an air of erraticism and leaves little room for individual performances to breathe.

View image in fullscreen‘Mandy McElhinney delivers the show’s most intriguing performance as Malisa Golightly.’ Photograph: ABC/Lisa Tomasetti

Much of what Shakedown dramatises is admittedly difficult to sculpt into compelling drama. Conversations between Centrelink employees and members of the public hardly scream “riveting”. Nor do scenes of royal commission investigators convening in sterile offices to piece together what happened. The dialogue is littered with words like “compliance”, “earned income”, “raw PAYG data”, “leave payments”, “bank credits”, “risk factor clusters”, “ombudsman’s report” and other terminology that could play a role in developing a cure for insomnia.

There’s a massively important story to be told here, but Shakedown is lacklustre from its opening scene, seemingly conceived as a reversal of conventional storytelling wisdom – “show don’t tell” becoming “let’s explain absolutely everything”. It kicks off with a midshot of Sarah Peirse (recently in the awesome detective series Treasure & Dirt) breaking the fourth wall as Catherine Holmes, former chief justice of Queensland, who led the royal commission into the robodebt scheme. She stares into the camera and delivers a long spiel, describing robodebt – in dialogue cribbed from the commission’s findings – as “an extraordinary saga of venality, incompetence and cowardice”.

Summaries like this have a time and place, narratively speaking, but are almost always more impactful when expressed organically through drama rather than directly articulated verbally, which feels like we’re being belted on the head with prescribed meaning. The irony is that while words such as Holmes’s may be real, in Shakedown they come across as fake and stagey.

View image in fullscreenJustine Clarke plays dignified public servant Colleen Taylor, and Arka Das plays another Centrelink employee Stephen. Photograph: ABC/Lisa Tomasetti

The same applies to entire scenes. Take a meeting in the first episode (this review encompasses all four) capturing a Centrelink gathering that begins with a statement from the boss, about as interesting as reading terms and conditions: “I just want to talk about today’s intranet update.” Nothing about what follows feels authentic. Not the boss, trotting out corporate-speak about moving from “manual to automatic, slow to fast, old to new”. Not the public servant who asks: “If we don’t review, how can we be sure the customer even has a debt?” Nor their colleague, who takes a grand moral stand, declaring “I won’t be a part of it!” before quitting on the spot and marching out.

Perhaps this moment, or something like it, occurred in real life, but here it feels almost comically laboured. The characters aren’t talking to each other so much as delivering carefully positioned talking points for the audience. There are some flickers of interest here and there, but overall this show is clunky and dull.