By Reatile Pitso, Freeman Masuku, Johan Hanekom, Stephen Mpanamana and Mvikeli Mpofu
In South Africa, where coal remains a dominant energy source, significant volumes of coal waste – estimated at 60 million tonnes annually – create environmental and safety risks. While circular economy approaches offer a potential route to managing this waste sustainably, limited local research has been conducted to evaluate the engineering performance of coal waste in asphalt.
The CSIR, the country’s multidisciplinary research organisation with a strong capability base in mobility and transport, was well positioned to address this research gap. The work also aligns with South Africa’s broader aspirations around sustainability, resource efficiency and the transition towards a circular economy.
We therefore set out to investigate whether coal waste could serve as a viable substitute for natural aggregates, such as sand, gravel and crushed stone, as well as active fillers in medium continuously graded asphalt wearing courses. The ultimate objective was to develop technically sound, cost-effective and environmentally compliant asphalt mixes (composite material made up of mineral aggregates and bitumen used in roads) that reduce reliance on virgin aggregates while maintaining, or potentially improving, asphalt performance.
Internationally, research on coal waste for road application in countries such as the United States of America, China, India, Iran, and Korea has demonstrated that incorporating coal waste into asphalt can improve pavement performance, reduce costs and address environmental pollution. The Virginia Department of Transportation, for example, found that asphalt containing coal waste achieved strength and durability comparable to or better than conventional mixes. Studies in China and Iran have also reported improvements in mechanical properties such as Marshall stability, tensile strength and resilience. In India and Korea, coal waste has successfully been used to replace natural aggregates, reducing construction costs while demonstrating no harmful environmental leaching.
Against this backdrop, the CSIR, in collaboration with Coaltech, initiated a project to explore the repurposing of coal waste in asphalt production as part of a broader move towards a circular economy. The key question was whether coal waste could serve as a viable substitute for some of the natural aggregates used in asphalt wearing courses – the top layer of roads – within the context of South African road construction. Could this approach reduce environmental impacts while improving material efficiency and maintaining, or even enhancing, road performance?
Coal waste fines and fly ash exhibit what is known as pozzolanic (binding) activity. This means that, when combined with other materials under the right conditions, they can contribute to the formation of hard, cement-like substances, despite having little cementing power. This characteristic, together with their fine particle size, makes them potentially suitable for use as fillers in asphalt mixes. Research suggests that these materials can enhance stability, stiffness and durability while reducing moisture susceptibility.
Aggregates, bitumen, lime and coal waste samples obtained from partners in the coal industry, were tested against relevant South African standards, including SANS 3001 and Sabita Manual 35 Aggregates, bitumen, lime, and coal waste samples sourced from industry partners were subjected to laboratory testing in accordance with applicable South African standards, including the SANS 3001 series and Sabita Manual 35. The testing was undertaken to characterise the materials and assess their suitability for incorporation into the proposed coal-waste-based asphalt mix for road pavement applications. The coal waste materials displayed acceptable grading and chemical characteristics for asphalt applications.
Laboratory tests showed that asphalt mixes containing coal waste matched or outperformed traditional mixes in terms of stiffness, deformation resistance and durability. The inclusion of coal waste also reduced moisture sensitivity without compromising strength. Leachate tests further indicated that coal waste could be used with minimal environmental restrictions. Laboratory evaluation of coal-waste-modified asphalt mixes assessed stiffness, resistance to permanent deformation, moisture sensitivity and durability, with results indicating performance comparable to or better than conventional mixes. Moisture sensitivity testing further showed that incorporating coal waste did not compromise mix strength and, in some formulations, improved resistance to moisture-induced damage. Environmental compatibility was assessed through leachate testing, whereby extracts from the coal-waste-containing materials were analysed for the potential release of environmentally harmful constituents, with results indicating concentrations within applicable regulatory or guideline limits.
South Africa’s extensive road network presents a significant opportunity to consume substantial quantities of coal waste in asphalt production. Naturally, adequate budgets would need to be available for the paving of unpaved roads and the resurfacing of existing roads. However, incorporating coal waste in asphalt could reduce the volume of material sent to landfill and support broader emissions-reduction objectives. The overall environmental impact appears to be relatively low if current paving levels continue; the overall environmental impact is expected to remain relatively low under continued use at current pavement application levels, based on the assessed material quantities and anticipated exposure conditions. However, the potential benefits could be substantially greater if high-risk waste piles or dumps were identified and used as sole material sources.
The research also demonstrated measurable cost savings, largely as a result of reduced aggregate and transport costs, provided transport distances remain limited. Sensitivity analyses confirmed the financial viability of the approach, particularly in regions located near coal mines and power stations.
To move the use of coal waste from an academic research topic to a practical solution – one in which coal waste is transformed from stockpiles into road construction material – several steps are recommended.
First, regional implementation strategies should be developed, with particular attention given to the proximity of coal waste sources to asphalt production facilities and road construction projects. We also need to conduct more pilot-scale trials to validate the results under practical conditions and modify coal waste properties to increase the quantity incorporated into asphalt without compromising performance and durability. In addition, we need to develop national standards and technical guidelines and conduct extensive testing across different geological and climatic regions. We also believe that we should look into expanding the use of coal waste beyond asphalt by including concrete, bricks and mine backfilling for broader coal waste valorisation.
Yes, coal waste can help us build better roads. It can be used safely, without compromising mechanical performance, durability or environmental compliance and in some cases, may even improve these properties. The asphalt mixes we tested met or surpassed South African asphalt design criteria.
It is a technically feasible, economically attractive and sustainable solution for South Africa’s road construction sector.
The CSIR team: Reatile Pitso – CSIR Senior Researcher, Freeman Masuku – Impact Area Manager, Johan Hanekom – CSIR Chief Rock Engineer, Stephen Mpanamana – CSIR Senior Mining Engineer, Mvikeli Mpofu – CSIR Researcher wrote this article