There was speculation in the local media as to whether Javier Milei, with tears in his eyes, was truly shaken at Pope Leo XIV’s departure from Argentina, or whether it was just good old-fashioned acting. Not only did the generally aggressive head of state tone down his verbal excess during the Holy Father’s visit to the country, but in the immediate aftermath he even seemed a bit more empathetic. In his first speech after the papal departure at the Endeavour Gala, Milei spoke about “human dignity” and even called on businessmen and entrepreneurs to act as “social benefactors.” He didn’t even attack his political opponents or insult journalists.

But by the time he made another speech, the libertarian had raised the heat a bit. Speaking at the Casa Rosada at the opening of an exhibition about founding father Manuel Belgrano, he praised him and announced he would seek re-election. No attacks there, but with Milei, what he posts online is as important as his actual words – via social media he said: “There are people willing to sink the ship once they realise they can’t be captain.” He continued to kicked it up a notch again when he met with business leaders at the CICyP annual dinner. Forced to refute speculation that his social media post was aimed at Patricia Bullrich, who has shown increasing signs of independence within his political space, Milei called the Peronist opposition “orcs” and blamed them for keeping Argentina’s country risk-premium excessively high. Then he remembered his old friends, the journalists, whom he accused of printing lies.

During a visit to the Central Bank to speak about monetary theory, Milei later compared himself to Alexander the Great, using an apparently apocryphal phrase: “I didn’t conquer half the world listening to idiots [in Spanish he used the term ‘inútiles’].” He was referencing those who question his economic policy path. Milei is gradually returning to his usual repertoire, including accusing his opponents of being “crooks” and questioning journalist’s partiality. While he hasn’t yet reached his pre-Pope levels of aggressiveness, the President’s tone is converging back to its usual state.

It seems plausible that Milei was emotionally shaken by the presence of the Holy Father, and that both his constraint and emotions were real. That he temporarily sought to align his message and tone with Pope Leo’s. He eliminated foul language from his social media posts and even spoke about “dialogue” and “respect” in a speech he gave in front of the pontiff at the Palacio Libertad. Milei, the “anarcho-capitalist” libertarian economist who has called social justice “an atrocity” even sought to build bridges with one of the pillars of Pope Leo’s (and Francis’) worldview by noting that it isn’t contrary to his ideology, in that both are substantiated by the Ten Commandments.  Milei had previously shown such conceptual acrobatics when he went from denouncing Pope Francis as the “incarnation of the Evil one on Earth” to calling him “the most important Argentine in history.”

Promises, promises

Are we seeing a “new and improved” Milei, who took in the spiritual and religious message from the Holy See and will now “turn the other cheek”? Totally unlikely and nearly impossible. The President will remain true to his nature, and also stick to his guns which have given him extraordinary electoral results. That means the insults, the foul language, the incessant posting on social media, the rock concerts – the full bag of tricks is still on the table.

But Milei has proven pragmatic at different points of his tenure, such as in the early days when he allowed his political teams to negotiate in order to pass marquee regulation including the omnibus ‘Ley de Bases’ mega-reform. He’s doing the same now with negotiations aimed at suspending the PASO primaries, which are being led by Senator Patricia Bullrich. The leader of the libertarian caucus in the Senate, the former security minister has highlighted her differences with Milei time and again, and is the only person who can do so without eliciting his wrath.

Bullrich said the President had crossed a red line when he called for a group of journalists to be burnt at the stake. She acknowledged Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva’s electoral victory in Brazil when the Milei administration was helping Flávio Bolsonaro escape to the United States, and disagreed publicly when the Casa Rosada refused to honor the Senate’s confirmation of Judge María Verónica Michellini’s posting because she’s a family member of a critical journalist, Hugo Alconada Mon. Still, Milei is going out of his way to make sure that she remains part of La Libertad Avanza, calling her a political “partner.” Former president Mauricio Macri, Bulllrich's former boss, never offered such treatment, even if there were words of praise for him.

Waiting for the assassins to return

Bullrich doesn’t generate such affection because she touches a soft spot in Milei’s heart. She’s made clear time and again that she wants to compete in next year’s elections, without shutting the door to a presidential bid. Sharing the ticket with Milei as vice-presidential candidate or running for mayor of Buenos Aires City are among her top options. And let’s not forget that Bullrich has a history of turning on her political allies, including the very recent “betrayal” of Macri’s PRO. A former leader of the party, Bullrich and her unsuccessful VP candidate, Luis Petri, quickly jumped ship to join Milei’s gang after failing to make the run-off in the 2023 election.

A recent poll by the AtlasIntel political consultancy places Bullrich as the best-ranking member of the current administration, with a 37-percent approval rate and a negative differential of 20 percentage points. Milei is one point behind, at 36-percent approval but counts with a wider differential (26 percentage points). Nobody else in the Milei camp comes even close. And at the top of the list are (incredibly) Cristina Fernández de Kirchner (41-percent approval, negative differential of 12 percentage points), Axel Kicillof (39 and minus 15), and Myriam Bregman (39 and minus 12). According to the figures, the President is hampered by a 60-percent rejection rate which has been on an upward trend for some 17 months. 

Unemployment is now the main concern among those polled, knocking off inflation, which had led the index in close correlation to the deterioration of the President’s image. Worries about the economic situation are growing and could overtake corruption in the coming months.

Milei could benefit Peronists by scrapping PASO primaries

The President and his political team are in campaign mode. In his recent speeches he confirmed he’s seeking re-election and said that his political strategist Santiago Caputo had predicted that they will win in the first round vote thanks to the “youth vote.” Most of the talk amongst analysts has been about the possibility of a run-off between Milei and a member of the opposition, most probably a Peronist, with Buenos Aires Governor Kicillof trying to edge out any competition. Sergio Massa, who was close last time, is looking to rain on the governor’s parade. Both of them have elevated negative figures in the recent poll (minus 54 percent for Kicillof and minus 63 percent for Massa).

Milei needs to keep Bullrich content and the Peronists divided to increase his chances of victory. The pragmatist will probably stay around for a while; his adherence to the teachings of the Church, probably not.