Logging in Central Victoria in 2024. A Coalition proposal to recover timber and fibre from public forests through ‘targeted thinning’ and fuel reduction has been widely criticised by the environment movement. Photograph: Nadir Kinani/The GuardianView image in fullscreenLogging in Central Victoria in 2024. A Coalition proposal to recover timber and fibre from public forests through ‘targeted thinning’ and fuel reduction has been widely criticised by the environment movement. Photograph: Nadir Kinani/The Guardian

As Victorians head to the polls, experts accuse both major parties of deserting environmental policy

The election year in Victoria began with devastating bushfires and record-breaking heat. Vulnerable grey-headed flying foxes perished in their thousands in the worst mass mortality event for the species since 2019’s black summer. Fires, which burned through more land than Black Saturday, destroyed most of the remaining Victorian habitat for endangered pink cockatoos and eastern bristlebirds.

A “shocker” of a ski season followed – the combined effect of global heating and an historic El Niño – while deadly H5 bird flu arrived in the state’s south-west, wreaking havoc among coastal birds, seals and dolphins. A key population of Leadbeater’s possums, the state’s animal emblem, were evacuated from their home at Yellingbo conservation area and placed in a specially developed refuge after their numbers halved in a matter of months – thought to have been taken by predators.

Yet less than a week from polling day, nature has barely rated a mention in the campaign. So why has the environment been so absent?

“We’ve got every single political party basically deserting the environment space,” says Prof David Lindenmayer, a conservation biologist at the Australian National University. “I can’t speak lowly enough about the quality of the environmental policies of the parties. It’s hard to believe how badly it’s unravelled in the last 12 years in Victoria.”

Labor’s track record is “woeful”, he says, while accusing the Coalition of plans to bring back native forest logging under the guise of bushfire management.

3:01What is an El Niño and how could it cause the hottest year on record? – video

A report released by the independent Biodiversity Council on Tuesday describes Victoria as the “nature-poorest state”. It finds inadequate funding, weakened protections and inaction have left the state’s biodiversity in “serious decline”. Populations of Victoria’s threatened plants and animals were 70% smaller than they were in 2000, Melbourne residents had the worst access to green spaces of any Australian capital city and forests continued to be cleared – for fire breaks and via other loopholes – despite a commitment to end native forest logging in 2024. Meanwhile funding for biodiversity halved and Parks Victoria had a third fewer staff now than in 2020-21, the report says.

Prof Sarah Bekessey, a conservation scientist at the University of Melbourne and lead councillor at the Biodiversity Council, says the state is facing an “extinction emergency”, with a real risk that species could be lost in the next term of government. She says the critically endangered Victorian grassland earless dragon was “one that jumps to mind immediately”, given the state government’s failure to protect its last wild population.

“Victorians deeply, deeply care about nature,” Bekessey says, with surveys consistently showing the vast majority supported more action to protect the environment.

View image in fullscreenBushfires burn near Longwood in northern Victoria in January. Ipsos polling shows voter concern for the environment peaked in 2020 after the black summer bushfires, but is now at the lowest level in 15 years. Photograph: Michael Currie/AAP

A Labor spokesperson says the government had “delivered real action to protect our environment so future generations can enjoy the best national parks in the world”. Its environment announcements in the campaign include support for a few local parks and $900,000 for Wildlife Victoria’s travelling vet service.

3:47Victoria’s election will be historic, no matter who wins. Here’s why – video

Jess Wilson’s Coalition has pledged $50m to establish a coastal environment resilience fund to tackle erosion and strengthen infrastructure, and to increase the number of park rangers. But the Coalition’s proposal to recover timber and fibre from 5,000 hectares of public forests through “targeted thinning” and fuel reduction each year has been widely criticised by the environment movement as native forest logging under the guise of fire management.

But the Coalition refutes that characterisation. “We aren’t bringing back native timber logging,” a spokesperson says. “The forest will come first. But if trees need to come down to reduce bushfire risk or for the health of the forest, then it makes sense to put that to its highest value, and in many cases that will be timber processing.”

Nationals MP Melina Bath told the Weekly Times the policy would deliver 100,000 to 200,000 tonnes of timber annually.

“That’s just logging,” says Lindenmayer. “It’s bullshit to say it’s about fire management. We know quite clearly that the way forests are thinned makes them more vulnerable to fire. And thinning actually takes out the habitat for animals like Leadbeater’s possum, which depends on the understory.”

skip past newsletter promotion

after newsletter promotion

“Victorians chose to leave native forest logging behind,” says Chris Schuringa, the nature campaigns coordinator at Environment Victoria. “The state government has spent more than $1bn transitioning the industry. Jess Wilson is living in a fantasy land if she thinks she can bring back native forest logging. It doesn’t make economic sense, it’s a disaster for the environment and has very, very low public support from Victorians.”

Schuringa says the Greens were the only party with a positive vision to protect forests, end all timber extraction apart from plantations, and close logging loopholes. During Tuesday’s leaders debate, the Greens leader, Ellen Sandell, said it was a “deep, deep shame” that the environment had been largely forgotten in the election. “We have a responsibility as governments and as politicians to be stewards of our environment for our kids and grandkids.”

Kos Samaras, director at polling group Redbridge, says most people still care about the environment, but it drops down the list of priorities at times of economic stress – “which we are seeing and experiencing right now”. However, Samaras says the environment remained a “very important” issue for younger voters, which could be a problem for Labor, given “the lack of policy in this space”.

Ipsos polling on the top issues facing Victoria shows voter concern for the environment peaked in 2020 – in the wake of the black summer bushfires – but is now at the lowest level in 15 years, a trend also reflected nationally.

A recent report commissioned by the Wilderness Society finds Victoria’s forests are worth more standing than cut down. The analysis finds nearly a third of the state’s economy, $210bn, depends on the natural environment: healthy forests supply water, parks drive regional tourism, coastal systems sustain fishers and trees shield towns from floods and keep neighbourhoods cool in a heatwave.

“The next Victorian government has an opportunity to halt the destruction of nature and start rebuilding, but it will take more than promises. We need proper funding, stronger laws and accountability for delivering results,” Bekessey says.

Lindenmayer says expanding parks and protected areas, such as the proposed Great Forest national park 90 minutes from Melbourne, could be a boon for both city residents and regional tourism. “It’s what the people of Melbourne want and need, we know that it will be good for the economy, and we know that it’ll be good for other elements of biodiversity that have declined dramatically.”

“It’s hard to deal with a constant diet of bad news,” he says. “What actually needs to happen is there needs to be some environmental wins, to give people hope.”