In brief: In a first such case under Ukraine’s martial law, a juvenile court in Rome has ordered the immediate return of a 12-year-old Ukrainian girl to her father in Ukraine. Ukraine’s human rights commissioner, Dmytro Lubinets, said on Friday, Nov. 20 that his office had spent six months on the case. The ruling comes months after Kyiv accused Italian courts of blocking the repatriation of Ukrainian children evacuated in 2022.

Italian Court Orders Child’s Return to Ukraine in First Such Case Under Martial Law

A juvenile court in Rome has ordered a 12-year-old Ukrainian girl to be returned to her father in Ukraine, in what Kyiv described as the first such ruling by an Italian court under martial law.

Ukraine’s human rights commissioner Dmytro Lubinets announced the move on Friday, Nov. 20, noting that a panel of four judges had ruled a day earlier that the girl, Valeriia, should be reunited with her parent without delay.

Follow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official.

“This is a precedent,” Lubinets wrote, explaining that other states generally do not return Ukrainian children who are abroad without parental care during martial law. “I can’t even begin to describe the immense work our team did,” he added.

The case marks a turn in an earlier dispute between Kyiv and Rome.

In June, Kyiv accused Italian courts were blocking the return of dozens of Ukrainian children evacuated in 2022, and Lubinets compared Italy’s conduct to Moscow’s illegal deportations.

Italian courts had refused to recognize the guardianship of the director of a Sumy children’s home over 25 minors taken to Naples, instead classifying them as unaccompanied minors and assigning them Italian guardians and host families.

Six months of casework

Valeriia’s case drew attention in June, when she went missing in Italy and the Ukrainian community there followed the search closely.

When she was found, it emerged that she had run away from her grandmother, with whom she had lived for about a year, because she wanted to return to her father in Ukraine.

Burnham, EU Leaders Agree Deals on Trade, Carbon Markets and Youth Mobility

An Italian court then placed her in the temporary care of the family of Andrea Querqui, mayor of the town of Ceccano. According to Lubinets, the family gave her a safe and caring home, but she kept speaking with her father by phone for hours each day.

The commissioner said that without intervention, the girl risked staying in Italy without parental care and losing any chance of rejoining her father.

Among the key obstacles was getting the father, Nazar, to Rome due to Ukraine’s martial law. Because of it, men of military age generally cannot leave Ukraine.

Lubinets said that his office worked on the case for half a year, sending dozens of requests to the relevant authorities, holding lengthy consultations with consular staff and partners, as well assembling the required documents.

According to him, the Italian court might not have ruled in the family’s favor had the father not appeared in person. In response, Lubinets’ office arranged the trip, and a staff member accompanied him.

Nazar’s appearance in the courtroom, Lubinets said, surprised both the judges and his daughter, who had not seen her father in a year and a half.

The hearing lasted about two hours before the court noted that the presence of both the father and the ombudsman’s representative weighed on its decision.

“Every child has the right to a family, safety, and the opportunity to be with their loved ones,” Lubinets concluded.

Wider push to return Ukrainian children

The ruling comes as Kyiv seeks broader international backing for returning illegally deported Ukrainian children.

Weeks after Bratislava drew scrutiny as the only EU member state not to endorse the Toronto Pledge on unlawfully deported children, Slovakia formally joined the International Coalition for the Return of Ukrainian Children on Nov. 2.

“Our shared goal is to see these children safely reunited with their families and back home,” Slovak State Secretary for EU Affairs Marek Eštok said at the time.

Meanwhile, in Washington, US President Donald Trump signed into law the Lindsey O. Graham Sanctioning Russia and Iran Act of 2026 on Sept. 18, formally establishing the forcible deportation, unlawful transfer, and unjust detention of Ukrainian children as statutory grounds for mandatory US sanctions.

Under the law, anyone found to have taken part in removing Ukrainian children, from officials and government institutions to companies that facilitated the transfers, can face asset freezes and travel restrictions.

Ukrainian officials have documented the unlawful transfer of nearly 20,000 Ukrainian children to both Russia and Belarus, where minors are subjected to forced naturalization, ideological indoctrination, and illegal adoptions.

Kyiv Post is Ukraine’s first and oldest English news organization, reporting since 1995. Its international reach – 90% of readers are outside of Ukraine – make it truly Ukraine’s global voice.