In brief: The successful landing of SpaceX’s Starship and the continued bombardment of Kyiv reveal two competing visions of the future. One is built on freedom, innovation, scientific progress, and the ability of free societies to pursue ambitious goals. The other is defined by imperial aggression and the denial of nations’ right to determine their own future.
For anyone who has sat in a bomb shelter in Kyiv and experienced the palpable fear of Russian bombardment, it was impossible not to feel a dissonance when reading the surge of praise and justifiable excitement on Sunday morning after SpaceX’s successful landing of their Starship. The thrill was suppressed by knowing that, at the very same moment, the skies of Kyiv were again filled with the sounds of explosions.
It’s a convenience, and a luxury, to be able to separate these two things. I dare say that Kyiv was not on the minds of the crowds at Starbase when this new generation of spaceship made its spectacular return into the mechanical chopsticks. It might even be reasonable for those people to demand that the sorrow of the world be put aside for a moment to focus on this stupendous new opportunity for humanity to reach across the Solar System.
Follow our coverage of the war on the @Kyivpost_official.
Likewise, residents of Kyiv, and indeed the whole of Ukraine, are completely forgiven for having little concern about potential missions to Mars and reduced costs of launching material to orbit while the bombs drop. The situations seem like worlds apart.
Yet it is important to bring both these situations into view at once, because they starkly present our options for the future.
Russia’s barbaric attack on Ukraine is everything that we hoped would be consigned to the past after the end of World War II and then again, at the end of the Cold War. A planet riven by imperial wars of aggression where might determines the future of nations, and powerful nations do deals over the heads of the expendable to carve the globe into spheres of influence. Respect for national borders and identity, and the freedom of nations and individuals to determine their own futures, was what many people thought would be the fruit of the end of Nazism and communism. Russia drags us back to this vision of humanity.
It is disappointing that the nation that helped end these horrors and establish the foundations of a new type of world, the US, has allowed these ghosts to triumph and now actively engages in attempts to convince Ukrainians to cede their land and to give up the defence of their liberty for the purpose of claiming a quick peace.
In the meantime, Ukrainians lose their lives and brute tyranny is given succour and encouragement to expand its uncompromising death cult. Embedded in all of this are strange changes in the accessibility of Starlink communications being used by Ukraine to defend itself – technology which has become a vital tool in its heroic efforts to prevent its own destruction.
By contrast, Starship, a product of American enterprise, scientific and technical excellence and of a nation that sees the Solar System as a chance for exploration and maybe new civilizations beyond Earth, is the child of a different side of America: The belief that free people should be allowed to dream big, set out to accomplish great things, and show humanity the way to use its imagination to improve the situation of civilization.
These two visions of American power sit uncomfortably together. Yet, a belief in free enterprise and individual liberty can exist at the same time as a government that wields its power in concert with other powers around the world, a state which makes agreements with other militarily powerful countries to decide who will project power in different hemispheres. The personification of these two futures is Elon Musk, who finds himself caught up in the questions about our future raised by Starship in the US and Starlink in Ukraine.
In the longer term, though, the two futures are utterly incompatible. No vision of a space-faring civilization will long endure while revanchist imperial wars of aggression are given tacit support and tyrants free rein to commit war crimes. This type of world will degrade all of us and transform the world into a place where there is little, if any, space for anyone to dream of peaceful settlement, on Earth or anywhere else.
The separation between these two emerging futures may feel convenient to those far away from the zones of conflict, but eventually the naïve daydream of security will be consumed by global disorder. Already, many Americans are feeling the pain of a shambolic foreign policy.
No matter what our space ambitions, eight billion of us on Earth will far eclipse any population on Mars for a long time to come. It is here that we must secure the conditions for freedom. Even if we do succeed in achieving permanent settlement among the planets, tyrants have every chance to extend their reach there as well. The Earth’s atmosphere is not a magical barrier to despotism. It makes sense for anyone who believes in the human future in space to direct a good portion of their time and effort to building a free Earth.
If we want a future of Starships, launching people and cities to distant worlds, then we must determine that here on Earth, we will defend societies that work toward peaceful democratic institutions, whose citizens want prosperity and the liberty to pursue scientific and technical projects with long-term benefit to humanity.
If at any point you are wondering what Ukrainians are fighting for, Elon, the answer is simple. They fight for the very things embodied in your own efforts: the freedom to think, to plan, to build better futures on Earth and maybe beyond. They fight for the principles behind that future. The cost of this fight is huge, but the prize is worthwhile and the price of failure existential.
This choice has hung over us since Ukraine was invaded, but the landing of Starship provides us with yet another opportunity to see clearly the fork in the road and where both paths lead.
What future do we decide to defend? Peaceful societies building spaceships and seeking improvement on Earth, or a world of conflict and aggression in which every day is another fight to defend our essential dignities and right to exist. We need to make up our minds and act.
Charles Cockell is Professor of Astrobiology at the University of Edinburgh.
The views expressed in this opinion article are the author’s and not necessarily those of Kyiv Post.