ADC secretariat (CREDIT: @ADCngcoalition)
The court also restrained Mr Ribadu “from parading himself as the ADC governorship candidate for Adamawa State.”
The Federal High Court in Abuja has nullified Tukur Ribadu’s emergence as the African Democratic Congress (ADC) governorship candidate for Adamawa State and ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) to restore Omar Suleiman as the party’s candidate.
Join the Premium Times WhatsApp Community For Quick Access To News and Happenings Around You.
Judge Obiora Egwuatu on Friday ordered the ADC to “forward Mr Suleiman’s details to INEC for publication as its governorship candidate.” He also directed the commission not to “recognise or publish” Mr Ribadu’s name as the party’s candidate.
The court also restrained Mr Ribadu “from parading himself as the ADC governorship candidate for Adamawa State.”
He made the order while giving judgement in a suit that followed the party’s decision to replace Mr Suleiman, who emerged as the winner of its governorship primary, with Mr Ribadu. Mr Suleiman challenged the substitution, insisting that he won the primary and that the party had no lawful basis to replace him.
Before considering the substantive dispute, Judge Egwuatu dealt with preliminary objections filed by the ADC and Mr Ribadu.
The ADC had asked the court to strike out the case, describing it as incompetent, statute-barred and an abuse of court process. Mr Ribadu also sought its dismissal for want of jurisdiction.
Among their arguments was that Mr Suleiman’s written address exceeded the page limit prescribed by the Federal High Court’s Election Proceedings Practice Directions. They said the address ran to 17 pages instead of the permitted 15.
Stay Ahead with Premium Times
But Mr Suleiman opposed the objection, arguing that the excess pages did not justify striking out the suit.
The judge acknowledged that the address exceeded the prescribed limit by two pages but refused to strike it out. He held that doing so would not serve the interests of justice.
The ADC also argued that the suit relied on a constitutional provision that did not apply to the party. Judge Egwuatu rejected the argument and said that he could not establish that the suit was incompetent at the preliminary stage.
The defendants further argued that the suit was statute-barred because Mr Suleiman failed to file it within the 14 days prescribed for pre-election matters under the Constitution.
They contended that he should have instituted the action earlier rather than wait until 6 August, when he filed the suit.
But the judge held that the action commenced within the constitutional time limit.
The defendants also argued that Mr Suleiman failed to exhaust the party’s internal dispute-resolution process before approaching the court.
The judge rejected this argument, reasoning that requiring the plaintiff to pursue the party’s internal process would have caused the 14-day constitutional period to expire. He held that Mr Suleiman was entitled to approach the court to protect his rights rather than allow the time limit to lapse.
No valid basis to replace him
On the merits of the case, the judge considered whether Mr Ribadu had challenged the primary election through the ADC’s appeal committee and whether the committee was properly constituted.
Mr Suleiman had argued that there was no properly constituted appeal committee and no evidence that Mr Ribadu appeared before such a committee to challenge the primary election result.
The ADC and Mr Ribadu maintained that an appeal was filed and that the committee reviewed the result before the party’s National Working Committee adopted its report.
According to their argument, the appeal committee submitted its report to the National Working Committee, which considered it and issued a resolution on 29 May.
Mr Ribadu also maintained that his name was submitted to INEC following the party’s decision to review the disputed result.
The judge examined documents from an earlier suit involving another aspirant, which Mr Suleiman relied on to support his position. The documents included processes filed by the ADC and statements by party officials who supervised the primary election.
He noted that the party’s processes in the earlier case did not disclose that Mr Ribadu had petitioned the appeal committee or that the committee had decided any such petition in his favour.
The judge also considered affidavits from the chairman and secretary of the ADC’s Adamawa State primary election committee and held that the officials denied that an appeal committee had been constituted to review the governorship primary.
The judge further relied on the primary election committee’s report, which stated that no petition had been received when it submitted its report. The report also recorded that no violence occurred at the election venue.
The court found no evidence that Mr Ribadu had successfully challenged the primary result through the party’s appeal process. It consequently upheld Mr Suleiman’s claim that he emerged as the winner of the primary and that the party had no “valid basis to replace him.”
Suleiman’s emergency and substitute
Mr Suleiman, a former managing director of the Nigerian Ports Authority and former Nigerian ambassador to the Democratic Republic of the Congo, won the ADC governorship primary in Adamawa State in May, defeating Mr Ribadu.
Reports of the primary election showed that Mr Suleiman polled 143,216 votes across the state’s 21 local government areas. Mr Ribadu came second with 56,801 votes, while another aspirant, Umar Uba, scored 20,343 votes.
READ ALSO: ADC politician Naja’atu Mohammed likens court ruling against party to June 12 election annulment
In late May, the chairman of the party’s Adamawa State Governorship Primary Committee, Nicholas Msheliza, announced the results and declared Mr Suleiman the winner.
However, the party’s national leadership later endorsed Mr Ribadu as its candidate, despite Mr Suleiman’s victory at the primary. The decision prompted Mr Suleiman to take the dispute to court.