Carlos Melconian offers his take on Argentina’s political and economic situation and puts forward a concrete proposal for Patricia Bullrich: that she become his vice-presidential running-mate in next year’s election and take charge of all areas of security.
During an interview aired on Modo Fontevecchia, broadcast on +Perfil and Radio Perfil (AM 1190), the 70-year-old economist assessed the direction of President Javier Milei’s government and the electoral outlook, combining political pronouncements with his customary warnings about the need to restore a more holistic approach to government.
Melconian holds a degree in Economics from the University of Buenos Aires (UBA) and a Master’s degree in Economics from Torcuato Di Tella University. In 1991, he co-founded the MS Consultores consultancy firm with Rodolfo Santángelo. He served as president of Banco de la Nación Argentina from December 2015 to January 2017, and previously held technical positions at the Central Bank. After leaving public office, he joined the MacroView consultancy firm, where he serves as vice-president.
Carlos, we’ve been friends for many years as a member of our council lunching monthly at Perfil’s offices. We might say I’m confessing a lack of objectivity to our audience. The October inflation rate of 2.2 percent is an obvious issue in the fundamentals of the economic perspective of President Javier Milei, who insists that inflation is always exclusively a monetary phenomenon. This issue no longer enters into a process of theoretical discussion but also practical confirmation.
Good day, Jorge. Well, I ratify the idea of a relationship over many years with always a strictly professional and journalistic attitude. The relationship is there, let’s not confuse the issue.Let me start with the following point, in terms of inflation – I have a confession to make to you.
I do not know if it is objective but I believe that it even favours the government, while I believe that they have simultaneously committed a huge error. If there was something which worried us as a team when preparing a programme, it was the disarray of relative prices in Argentina.
Let’s explain that. In the final analysis, inflation is a number averaging out the great many goods and items which go into a family shopping-basket – electricity, gas, the car, food and everything else. If you add wages, pensions and the dollar, we’re talking about relative prices. No country can even sustain indefinitely notorious differences among all that because one day it explodes. You cannot have major differences between the family shopping-basket and the other items I mentioned to you because, sooner or later, those beneath want to go up and those above do not want to go down. That is what is called relative prices.
Second question: an enormous disarray. Taking the five years prior to December 10, 2023, you have the crazy situation of an accumulated inflation of 1,500 percent – I’m not making this up – ranging from 2,500 percent for some prices and 400 percent for others. Really crazy, eh?
Everything in the lower range was what the previous administration had repressed, especially public services and the dollar, while the upper range in some way abused all the money printed in the monetary disarray. So when our team saw what was being done there, one thing was very clear to us – no stability plan was possible. There was no chance of saying inflation was going to be such and such a number on any given day, using no Keynesian or monetarist theory or anything you like over the following 14 to 20 months. Whether fixing or freeing the exchange rate, none, absolutely none; I’m confiding to you.
The question then became what we should do first. Well, first fix the relative prices. The first question we asked, I swear to you, was: Whoever corrects relative prices and stays in office? Look at what I’m confessing to you – is it worth becoming a minister here to fix such a shambles? Just ask [2002 Economy Minister] Jorge Remes Lenicov. So first you have to fix all that and then you can launch a stability plan. When it is said that [Carlos] Menem and [minister Domingo] Cavallo gave us convertibility, Menem became president on July 8, 1989 and convertibility was launched in March, 1991. In between there was the Bunge y Born Plan and more hyperinflation with double-digit monthly inflation. Relative prices were brought into line by letting them flow. That is one thing but how long it was going to take us to fix it was another question.
So what has happened. The tremendously serious error committed by this government and the President himself, who says that his studies have shown him that you can grow without money. I cannot understand that. The first time I heard him talking about the Austrian school, I asked myself in my ignorance where the Austrian school or monetary approaches came into it. Rodolfo Santángelo has worked for five years calculating the demand for money and monetary approaches in the Central Bank. He did that and every time he enlightens me about monetary issues, he tells me things which are very difficult to know beforehand. So that story that you are going to start [with inflation] of zero dot something and then it is going to collapse is an abuse of language which affects presidential credibility.
After this confession, do you understand me? A process of bringing relative prices into line is on the march in Argentina and they should not freak out any further in trying to know when inflation is going to come down. When you increase electricity bills ninefold, wages will suffer so you have to appreciate the exchange rate because you cannot let it fall behind. If you ask me to tell you what’s up, I say to you: Hang on because it’s on the move. What I’m telling you is not irresponsible, it’s honest.
So what is happening? What are we doing every time we look at inflation? Whatever happened to that [monthly] two percent? Menem took 33 months to lower [inflation] from a monthly two percent to 1.5 percent. Like I’ve been telling you from the first day of the Milei government, I do not know, from what they have done, what their programme, their road map or their monetary and exchange rate policies are. There is no chance of single-digit annual inflation under Milei and I’m saying that for the next year, included. So stabilising inflation in Argentina remains a task for the next government. The best thing which this government can do, with a political cost if they do it well, is to restore order to relative prices.
I can already tell you, with yesterday’s numbers, where we are today. Why? Because some things are still missing. I was taking a look today: 34 percent of prices have gone up by an annual 50 percent because electricity, gas, transport, petrol, medicine and, fundamentally, food have stayed on the move. And 40 percent of prices like cars, fruit, restaurants and garments are advancing very much below all that. They are all being disciplined by recession, not even opening up the economy to Chinese imports. In between others are floating with the wages and the exchange rate still begging.
In other words, even with the hope Leo XIV bought us and even with the Argentine opportunities with oil, gas and lithium, we should not mix apples and oranges when it comes to prices. We have this problem and it will take a while. I want to tell you like it is – a circle which could be virtuous or vicious but is currently the latter during this process. So on the basis of all this, you could ask me and it would be totally a common-sense question – when at the start Milei pegged the dollar at 800 pesos to begin correcting that circuit and got after public service billing in order to start correcting it but did not give anything to wages and pensions, he was starting an inflationary circuit which was seen as a success because it lowered an annual 300 percent to 30 percent. Was that circle going to leave casualties and new challenges? Most definitely, yes. You imagine that I was going to increase public service charges by 20 to 25 percent, just correcting them according to annual inflation without bearing in mind how far behind they are. And Milei’s 800-peso dollar today would be 2,200 not 1,500 pesos because that is how much the dollar has lagged, without talking about wages in both the private and public sectors and pensions, which started to be automatically corrected by the previous inflation.
So, with this message, your question is very useful for this focus as a first question. Next month let us stop looking at bananas, apples or the gas billing for cold areas when the global focus is the big challenge, something which needs to be fixed no matter what and about which there is no certainty. That is why I have much respect for communication over the formal but the presidential style [of communication], forget it. You cannot shoot your mouth over these things and nowadays it is cumulative. You can tell me: we have progressed. But new backlogs have accumulated in public service billing and the exchange rate without mentioning wages. Why? Because when fixing that, you go finding virtuous circles in some things and the continuity of vicious circles in others. That’s why guys who have not won Nobel prizes come along and say: “This can take five years or seven.” Israel, Portugal... The only place where they said it had collapsed in one August is here, creating a false illusion which hits prestige and confidence. Now the President can shoot his mouth but his team has to understand this. If they do not understand this ABC, they’re up to being finance ministers, nothing more.
Let me bring up an old axiom: the message is always determined by the person receiving it, not issuing it – i.e. each person interprets the message according to what they themselves believe. So, listening to you, I think that what is probably happening is that the person delivering [the message] is also responding to a demand of the society receiving it.
There is the belief that inflation can be lowered in one or two years because of the expectations created by the convertibility plan without counting the two previous years of Menem’s meltdown to arrive at those conditions. Cavallo himself, two months before his convertibility plan, devalued the peso 100 percent. Or the Austral Plan, which managed a lower rate of inflation in its second year, proceeding from much higher rates. Those two above plans had different degrees of success. One really successful one was the Plan Real in Brazil. At the end of its third year, its highest inflation rates were already lower than the current ones. So while it is valid that thinking that [inflation] can be lowered to single digits is over-optimistic, there are now cases of it being lowered to a single digit in three years. Why?
Well. due to different idiosyncrasies, formats, history, many things. I mean, the disarray of relative prices in December [2023] in Argentina was huge. I’ll throw you out a number – electricity billing had to be multiplied tenfold. Bus fares, which in Latin America average a dollar, cost 10 cents here. Ditto for fuel prices. I’ll tell you more, when you talk about momentum, which is true, the momentum was different. There is less of a problem of momentum here, rather this vicious circle which I have just mentioned. There was a delicate momentum when there was a steady three-digit annual inflation over many years because the contracts were phenomenally index-linked. You could not put a stability plan in motion with 12-month contracts at an annual 300 percent because the inflation there was never going to come down.