政府开支挤压发展
来源 Express Tribune 巴基斯坦论坛快报6 小时前
内容摘要
本条为 英文 原文,标题与摘要按原语言呈现。
80%的省级支出用于经常性费用;新省份的逻辑受到质疑
全文
The ever-expanding administrative machinery of Pakistan is putting additional pressure on public finances at a time when the country needs to generate millions of jobs, attract private investment and accelerate development spending.
With more than 80% of provincial expenditure consumed by recurrent costs, weak local government financing and persistent delays in public-private partnership projects, questions are emerging over whether existing governance structures are delivering value for the resources allocated to them.
Nearly 3.5 million people enter Pakistan's labour force every year, while unemployment among graduates aged 20-24 has reached 32.8%, rising to 42.3% among women, according to a research report published by the Institute of Cost & Management Accountants of Pakistan (ICMA) International.
It argues that administrative arrangements need to be aligned with changing economic realities, particularly the country's growing employment requirements and limited fiscal capacity.
The report, titled ICMA's Fiscal Vision for Pakistan: Aligning Administrative Structures with Economic Realities, highlights the disconnect between the size of the workforce entering the economy and the government's ability to facilitate productive employment through investment, entrepreneurship and regional economic development.
The pressure is particularly visible in public finances, where provincial governments spend more than four-fifths of their budgets on recurrent expenditures, leaving limited fiscal space for development initiatives. At the same time, local governments accounted for less than 5% of total government expenditure in 2024, highlighting the limited financial authority available to institutions closest to citizens and businesses.
The report suggests that expanding administrative establishments without clearly defining responsibilities and financing arrangements could further increase government expenditure without necessarily improving public service delivery.
"Pakistan cannot continue adding administrative layers and expect them to automatically produce economic development," said Ali Arif, an industrialist. The real issue is that businesses face multiple government departments, overlapping regulations and lengthy approval processes, while the cost of maintaining the administrative structure continues to rise.
"Now we are in a debate of creating new provinces, without even realising that businesses are already tired of inter-provincial trade and business issues, after the 18th Amendment. More provinces mean more stakeholders, more consultations, and of course more administrative machinery, which may create more mess than betterment," Arif added.
The problem extends beyond the size of government establishments to the effectiveness of institutions responsible for facilitating investment. The federal government's public-private partnership pipeline, for instance, contains 47 projects, including 22 qualified and 25 non-qualified projects. However, only one has reached the concession agreement stage, indicating significant weaknesses in moving projects from planning to implementation.
The slow progress raises questions about the government's capacity to prepare commercially viable projects, undertake technical and financial assessments and coordinate between federal and provincial institutions. Private investment cannot be mobilised simply by announcing infrastructure pipelines if projects remain stuck in administrative and procedural stages.
The employment situation adds another dimension to the challenge. Federal recruitment in 2024 attracted 274,566 applications for just 1,722 positions, reflecting intense competition for limited public-sector employment. While government jobs remain attractive to graduates seeking financial security, the scale of applications also highlights the pressure on an economy that has struggled to generate sufficient productive employment outside the public sector.
"The government has become an increasingly expensive administrator but has not developed the institutional capacity required to act as an effective facilitator of economic activity," said a former official of the State Bank of Pakistan. "Investors do not need more offices and departments; they need predictable policies, faster approvals and officials who can resolve problems rather than pass files between institutions," he added.
However, the challenge is not simply about reducing government expenditure or cutting administrative establishments. Recurrent spending also includes essential obligations such as salaries, pensions, education and healthcare. Any attempt to contain these costs without improving institutional efficiency could weaken public services rather than strengthen fiscal management.
The ICMA report draws on administrative and fiscal experiences from seven countries and argues that Pakistan should prioritise institutional effectiveness over the creation of additional administrative units. It recommends strengthening existing divisional and district institutions, improving fiscal devolution to local governments, removing overlapping regulations and sharing specialised technical resources across different levels of administration.
It also calls for integrated regulatory frameworks, digital approval mechanisms and clearly assigned institutional responsibilities to reduce the compliance burden on businesses and improve accessibility for citizens.
For Pakistan, where fiscal constraints continue to limit development spending and millions of new workers are entering the labour market, the effectiveness of government institutions is becoming an increasingly important part of the economic reform agenda. The challenge is not merely to reorganise the administrative map, but to ensure that public spending translates into productive economic opportunities.
全文由来源方 Express Tribune 巴基斯坦论坛快报 通过 RSS 提供,版权归原作者所有。
本站仅提供标题与摘要索引,完整内容与版权均归原发布方所有,请点击原文链接阅读。
前往原文- 所属频道
- 国际
- 所属地区
- 印度
- 原文语种
- English
- 条目编号
- world-19948d93
评论 0 条评论
还没有评论,来抢沙发