Former Capitec employee loses bid to overturn debarment over R400 debit-order reversal.
A former Capitec Bank employee has lost his bid to have his debarment overturned after the Financial Services Tribunal found that he had solicited and received R400 from a client in exchange for reversing a debit order.
The tribunal dismissed Tseliso Letele’s application for reconsideration, finding that Capitec had acted correctly when it debarred him over allegations of dishonesty and misconduct.
Letele, who worked as a service consultant and was registered as a financial services representative, was debarred by the bank on May 20, 2026, after an internal disciplinary process found that his conduct fell short of the honesty, integrity and good-standing requirements expected in the financial services industry.
The allegations stemmed from an incident on September 6, 2025, at Capitec’s East London Terminus 3 branch.
According to the notice of intention to debar, a client approached Letele seeking to exchange mutilated banknotes because of financial difficulties.
Letele allegedly told the client that R1,000 was available in his bank account and that he needed to pay him R400 in exchange for access to the funds.
The bank alleged that Letele subsequently processed a debit order reversal on the client's account without the client's knowledge or consent, despite receiving R400 from the client as payment.
Letele denies dishonesty
Capitec notified Letele of its intention to debar him on April 23, 2026, giving him an opportunity to make written representations explaining why the decision should not be taken.
In his submissions, dated April 29, 2026, Letele denied any dishonesty.
He later challenged the debarment before the Financial Services Tribunal, arguing that the evidence did not establish, on a balance of probabilities, that he had solicited or received money from the client.
He further argued that the client had authorised the debit order reversal, that the investigation was incomplete and that he had no motive to commit an act of dishonesty.
Letele also asked the tribunal to consider his clean disciplinary record with the bank.
He was debarred on May 20, 2026, and lodged his reconsideration application on July 7, 2026.
He subsequently applied to have the debarment suspended pending the outcome of his reconsideration application. However, that application was dismissed on July 30, 2026, after he failed to demonstrate a reasonable prospect of success.
Tribunal finds client’s version more credible
In considering the matter, the tribunal examined whether the evidence was sufficient to establish dishonesty, particularly in the absence of footage showing the alleged payment.
The tribunal accepted Capitec's argument that the evidence had to be considered as a whole, rather than focusing solely on the absence of video footage.
It found that the client's version was more probable than Letele's explanation, noting that the client had remained consistent in his account of what had happened.
The tribunal said the cumulative evidence established, on a balance of probabilities, that Letele had solicited and received R400 from the client to reverse the debit order and provide him with funds, while the client was unaware of how the transaction was being facilitated.
It also rejected Letele's argument that the client had authorised the debit order dispute.
The tribunal noted that the client could neither read nor write English and had been misled about the nature and effect of the transaction.
It said a person in those circumstances could hardly be regarded as having authorised the transaction.
On Letele's argument that he had no motive to act dishonestly; the tribunal agreed with Capitec that motive was irrelevant to the reconsideration proceedings.
It also found that his clean service record did not change the outcome of the debarment dispute.
The tribunal explained that financial services representatives are required to meet the fit-and-proper standards prescribed under the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act (FAIS Act) and Board Notice 194 of 2017.
These standards include requirements relating to honesty, integrity and good standing.
The tribunal found that Capitec had followed the required procedure, including notifying Letele of its intention to debar him and allowing him an opportunity to respond.
It said it found no fault with the bank's procedure or its findings on the substantive allegations.
CCMA proceedings rejected as further evidence
Letele also sought permission to introduce further evidence relating to proceedings before the Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration (CCMA).
However, the tribunal dismissed this application, finding that the labour proceedings were irrelevant to the reconsideration application.
It explained that the CCMA proceedings dealt with labour-related issues, while the tribunal was required to determine whether Letele met the honesty and integrity requirements applicable to financial services representatives under the FAIS Act.
In its final order, the tribunal dismissed both Letele's application to submit further evidence and his application for reconsideration.