Old News is a new initiative by Amwaj.media to connect the past to the present. Through “reporting” on pivotal moments in history, we aim to provide a richer backdrop for current dynamics in the region.

 

The story: Several hundred gunmen have seized the Grand Mosque in Mecca, proclaiming one of its leaders as the Mahdi, a messianic figure. The occupation of Islam’s holiest site began during dawn prayers, with thousands of worshippers now held hostage. There are reports of fatalities as Saudi security forces clashed with the militants during the takeover.

The seizure has drawn condemnation across the globe, while competing claims blaming Iranian, Saudi or US groups are spreading across the region. The Saudi government is on high alert, but religious stipulations on the use of force in Mecca complicate any attempt to end the siege.

The coverage: Gunmen occupied Mecca’s Grand Mosque during dawn prayers on Nov. 20, 1979. Estimates put the number of assailants at between 200 and 500.

  • The militants mingled with worshippers, having smuggled rifles, pistols and submachine guns into the mosque in coffins, which are commonly brought in for funeral prayers.

  • When the imam finished, the assailants took out their weapons, seized the microphone and locked the 26 gates of the holy site, posting two guards at each entry point.

  • A telegram from the US embassy in Saudi Arabia, citing a cabinet minister, says the gunmen had earlier also "been able to bring in trucks loaded with arms and dates for food."

It is unclear how many people were in the mosque as the siege unfolded. One Saudi minister estimates the number at 40,000–50,000. Not all are being held hostage, however, with those trapped in the thousands.

  • According to a Reuters wire, family members of Saudi Oil Minister Sheikh Ahmed Zaki Yamani are among the hostages.

Reading a statement as the microphone was seized, a member of the assailants was proclaimed as the Mahdi, a messianic figure in Islam.

  • In the same statement, the group denounced the ruling House of Saud as corrupt, accusing it of secularizing the Kingdom and pursuing closer ties with the west.

  • An Iranian pilgrim who witnessed the attack recounts that the proclaimed Mahdi was “fishy” and had been wandering the area for days, stopping to speak to people in the streets.

A shootout between Saudi National Guards and the gunmen broke out almost as soon as the siege began, but the occupiers have not been dislodged from the mosque compound.

  • The death toll is unconfirmed. Pilgrims, gunmen and security personnel are reported to have been killed—including by militants who have scaled the Grand Mosque’s minarets.

  • Little else is known about events inside the holy compound, as Saudi officials have imposed a communications blackout and cut telephone and telex lines to the area.

The New York Times reports confusion about the affiliations of the militants.

  • Some in the region speculate that the siege is tied to the Islamic Revolution in Iran led by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini earlier this year, which overthrew Shah Mohammad Reza Pahlavi. “It is the atmosphere of fanaticism created by Khomeini that made this possible,” a Lebanese journalist told the Times, alluding to Shiite millenarianism.

  • While some early reports claimed that the gunmen are followers of Khomeini or tied to the Shiite Muslim community, those allegations have been quickly discounted.

The Saudi Ministry of Defense blames the attack on “a group of renegades to the Islamic religion,” without naming any organization or individual.

  • Meanwhile, a telegram from the US embassy backs accounts that point to local involvement, saying that the mosque seizure is led by a young “Saudi religious fanatic.”

Meanwhile, Iran is pointing at Israel and the United States. The conflicting claims are feeding a web of competing claims across the region.

  • Radio Tehran has broadcast a statement by Ayatollah Khomeini saying that “it is not farfetched to assume that this act has been perpetrated by the criminal American imperialism.”

  • Khomeini also alluded to a purported role for “Zionism,” alleging that “certain criminal hands are trying to split the Muslims and make Islamic revolutions look ugly.”

Rumors of alleged Israeli and US involvement have been further fueled by witness accounts of the gunmen carrying Israeli Uzi submachine guns.

  • Amid the competing claims, mobs in Pakistan have stormed and set fire to the US embassy in Islamabad, killing at least one US Marine. American cultural centers in Lahore and Rawalpindi have also been torched.

The context/analysis: The timing of the attack carries importance. Nov. 20 is the first day of the Islamic lunar year 1400.

  • “Traditional beliefs” hold that the Mahdi, a renewer of the faith, will appear in Mecca on the initial day of a new century. In this context, the militants appear to have timed their operation to lend weight to their messianic claims.

  • Shiite Muslims mark the 680 CE martyrdom of Prophet Muhammad’s grandson Hussein during the first month of the Islamic calendar. This initially led some observers to link the siege to Shiites with ties to the newly founded Islamic Republic of Iran.

  • Coming amid the ongoing crisis between Tehran and Washington that began with the seizure of the US embassy in Tehran by Iranian radical students earlier this month, the occupation of Mecca’s Grand Mosque has put a possible Iranian connection at the front of many minds.

The US embassy in Saudi Arabia has named 26-year-old “Muhammad Abdallah” as the leader of the mosque takeover.

  • Among the few available details on the purported ringleader is that he attended three years of sharia classes in Riyadh, leaving the institute before finishing his studies. He has previously clashed with the authorities and spent four months in prison over activities "inimical to the government.”

  • Abdallah is notably described as a member of the Utayba, a prominent tribe with close associations to the Saudi military.

  • Of the 13 militants captured by security forces on Nov. 20, one is said to have been a Pakistani national. However, witness accounts say most gunmen are members of the Utayba tribe.

Armed intervention to bring an end to the mosque occupation is made more complex by religious stipulations relating to Mecca.

  • The Qur’an and hadiths both treat Islam’s holiest site as a sanctuary, where bloodshed and fighting have long been forbidden—even prior to the advent of Islam in the seventh century CE.

  • These dynamics have left the Saudi government in a bind, as it must avoid violating the sanctity of Mecca’s Grand Mosque, including through further bloodshed.

The future: Despite the religious obstacles, Saudi officials are reportedly set to begin discussions with Islamic scholars to find a way to allow a military operation.

  • The complexities of what is unfolding has left many observers wondering whether Riyadh might respond to the unprecedented seizure of the Grand Mosque by doubling down on modernization, or by embracing more conservatism to appease traditionalist currents.

  • The clerics who hold the power to issue a religious edict allowing a violent storming of Islam’s holiest site are notably traditionalists. Saudi authorities may have to allow such clergymen more influence over society and the state once the dust from the siege settles.

There are also reports that Saudi reinforcements have been sent to the area. Military hospitals in Jeddah and Riyadh have been instructed to prepare to receive the wounded.

  • Defense Minister Prince Sultan bin Abdulaziz Al Saud and Interior Minister Prince Nayef bin Abdulaziz Al Saud are reportedly on their way to Mecca to oversee the response to the crisis.

Unsubstantiated claims of Israeli and US backing for the mosque siege are fueling anger across the region.

  • Ayatollah Khomeini’s allegations, combined with the information blackout imposed by Saudi authorities, is stoking unrest reported in parts of India, Libya and Pakistan.

  • Some fear that further American cultural and diplomatic facilities in the region may become the target of mob violence in the coming days.

For now, the most credible account attributes the occupation of the Grand Mosque to a Saudi group. That would pose a serious challenge to the authority of King Khalid bin Abdulaziz Al Saud.

  • The alleged siege leader is said to have ties to puritanical Salafist ideology, long associated with the House of Saud. Notably, the Saudi National Guard is rooted in the Ikhwan, the religious tribal force that helped unite the Kingdom earlier this century.

  • In recent years, the Saudi monarchy has sought to distance itself from more hardline religious positions in favor of a more moderate approach to statecraft and religion.