These days, there are many gadgets to help you learn how your lifestyle affects your sleep. A consumer tech journalist tested them to find his favorites.View image in fullscreenThese days, there are many gadgets to help you learn how your lifestyle affects your sleep. A consumer tech journalist tested them to find his favorites.

Get a better night’s sleep with monitoring and guidance from smartwatches, smart rings, smart bands and sleep earbuds

The best sleep masks and best Bluetooth sleep masks

Getting quality sleep is just as crucial as getting enough sleep. And how you feel in the morning only tells part of the story. Smartwatches, smart bands, smart rings and sleep earbuds can all help fill in the details: how long it took you to doze off, how long you spent in deep sleep, how restless you were, your resting heart rate, even if you have night-time breathing difficulties.

Armed with this information, you can learn how your lifestyle affects your sleep. Maybe your after dinner cappuccino triggers a night of tossing and turning, or you’re more restful after evening workouts. As the wise GI Joe once said, knowing is half the battle. And the more you know about your sleep, the better chance you have of improving it.

At a glance: the best sleep trackers in the US

At a glance: the best sleep trackers in the US

Why you should trust me

View image in fullscreenI have reviewed hundreds of products in the sleep and fitness space. Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

As a consumer technology journalist for more than two decades, I began wearing fitness trackers in the early 2010s and have since reviewed hundreds of products in the sleep and fitness space. After spending more than 15 years tracking my sleep nightly, I have a deep understanding of how wearables work, which brands and products are reliable and how to best interpret app data.

How I tested

I wore up to five wearables at a time (two wrist devices, two rings, and earbuds) for at least seven nights each. Every morning, I plotted sleep data into a spreadsheet, including duration, sleep stages (light, REM, deep, awake), along with average sleep heart rate and heart rate variability (HRV) when available.

The Oura Ring 5 served as our benchmark for accuracy, since it is widely considered to be among the most accurate consumer wearables for sleep tracking. A study by the Multidisciplinary Digital Publishing Institute (MDPI), for example, found Oura Ring’s data to be virtually identical to a polysomnogram (PSG) for all sleep stage measurements – that’s the gold standard method they use in sleep labs.

View image in fullscreenEach morning, I plotted sleep data into a spreadsheet. Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

I also evaluated each tracker for design (is it comfortable to wear, especially overnight?), battery life (do I have to charge it frequently?), and the companion app (is it confusing or easy to read?).

Overall, I tested 11 wearables, some of which I spent significant time with before while reviewing them individually. Other wearables I have recently evaluated that I am confident would not make the cut or that have been replaced by newer models are listed as well.

I keep certain products on hand for future comparative reviews. Some products were sent specifically for consideration in this piece and were returned to the manufacturer if requested, except earbuds for hygienic reasons.

Best overall sleep tracker:
Oura Ring 5

View image in fullscreen Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

Best overall sleep tracker:
Oura Ring 5

$299 at Oura $299 at Amazon

Not only is the Oura Ring 5 the sleekest and slimmest smart ring out there, it’s also the most accurate and easiest to live with.

Why we love it: Part gadget, part fashion accessory, the Oura Ring 5 comes in six color options, from traditional black to elegant Deep Rose. The barely-there design is so minimalist you’ll forget you’re even wearing it, yet it accurately captures detailed sleep data, including efficiency, restfulness, latency and timing.

Easy-to-read bar graphs in the app let you know what areas need improvement. Had restless sleep? Maybe you need to refrain from consuming liquids before bed to avoid nightly trips to the bathroom. Do you take too long to fall asleep? Look into softer lighting, cooler temperatures, white noise or less screen time right before bed. I love the “sleep debt” figure that continuously calculates the discrepancy between how much sleep you got v how much you need. It motivated me to make better decisions to close the gap.

If the info from the app isn’t enough, the Oura Advisor AI assistant is like having your own personal (virtual) sleep coach. Ask it questions about your sleep, such as how to improve, or even ideas for a good before-bed snack.

It’s a shame that … You need a $6 monthly subscription to benefit from all the great features of Oura Ring 5. And even though the battery lasts for about six to nine days, some competitors last longer. Plus, it only comes with a wired charging dock – you need to buy the wireless charging case separately.

Finish options: Silver, Brushed Silver, Gold, Deep Rose, Black, Stealth

Subscription: Required for all meaningful data, $6 monthly or $70 annually

Best budget:
Fitbit Air

View image in fullscreen Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

Best budget:
Fitbit Air

$99 at Amazon $100 at Best Buy

This incredibly thin wristband is inexpensive and free of distractions, but also impressively accurate.

Why we love it: With no screen, the Fitbit Air doesn’t bombard you with notifications and data; it just works passively in the background. When you want to know more – about sleep, steps, heart rate – open the app, sync and explore. The sensors sit on the inside of a thin strap that is incredibly comfortable to wear all day and overnight. It comes in fabric or metal mesh, but Google also offers a silicone accessory band.

The Fitbit Air’s data matched the data from our benchmark Oura Ring 5, closer than any of the other device I tested. This includes total sleep, deep sleep, HRV and near-identical heart rate readings throughout the testing period. The only big discrepancy came from awake time, where it deviated from the Oura by about 40 minutes on average. For example, one night, the Oura Ring 5 logged 58 minutes of awake time, while Fitbit Air only counted 16 awake minutes.

It’s a shame that … You need a $10 monthly subscription to Google Health Premium to unlock detailed sleep analysis and an AI coach, but it does provide enough value to justify it. Battery life of seven days is decent, but it’s not as good as other screenless models.

Sizes: One size (130-210mm wrist size for textile/polyurethane), 130-175 or 165-210 mm (silicone)

Finish options: Obsidian, Berry, Lavender, Fog

Material: Recycled polycarbonate and PBT plastics, silicone

Subscription: Google Health Premium, $10 monthly or $100 annually (optional)

Best for iPhone users:
Apple Watch Series 12

View image in fullscreen Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

Best for iPhone users:
Apple Watch Series 12

$329 at Amazon $329 at Best Buy

The Apple Watch may be best known for flashy apps, fitness tracking and endlessly customizable bands, but it also makes a great sleep tracker.

Why we love it: The newest Apple Watch looks similar to the last few generations, but it now comes in ceramic, titanium or scratch-resistant aluminum, along with new finishes, including the lovely Dark Bronze of my review sample. I found it comfortable to wear overnight, and the data is easy to read from the watch face and the Health app.

After many years of wearing different Apple Watch models, I have noticed they often overstate deep sleep and understate awake time. This remains true for the newest model, but it comes pretty close to the Oura in tracking other sleep data, with the smallest differential for sleep duration, stages, sleep heart rate and HRV. It also had the closest REM readings to Oura of any device.

Beneath the basic stats, you can also dive deeper and compare your average sleep for the year to date with the year prior, providing value for longtime Apple Watch wearers. Like only a few peers, the Apple Watch can detect the breathing anomalies that align with sleep apnea. It’s not an official test – but it provides enough info to help you decide whether to consult a medical professional.

Besides tracking sleep, the Apple Watch is also a perfect iPhone companion for notifications, fitness tracking, Siri AI voice assistance, and with Apple’s new Health Sensing System, accurate heart-rate tracking.

It’s a shame that … The battery only lasts 24 hours per charge. You also need an iPhone, so Android owners are out of luck.

Finish options: Dark Bronze, Light Gold, Black, Space Grey (aluminum), Radiant Gold, Natural (titanium), Pearl White, Night Blue (ceramic)

Battery life: Up to 24 hours (38 hours in Low Power Mode)

Best for Android users:
Google Pixel Watch 5

View image in fullscreen Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

Best for Android users:
Google Pixel Watch 5

$300 at Best Buy $300 at Amazon

One of the most beautiful Android smartwatches you can buy is also an excellent tool to collect accurate sleep data and get AI-based guidance for adopting better sleep habits.

Why we love it: This comfortable-to-wear smartwatch for Android owners does a fairly good job of calculating sleep and stages, and especially HRV. You can also see how various factors such as restlessness and time-to-sleep compare with the typical range for people of your same age and gender. Its biggest weakness is inconsistent REM times, which were sometimes way above or way below, and other times spot on.

You need a Google Health Premium subscription ($10 monthly) to unlock sleep breathing trends, and AI Coach to ask questions about your sleep. But you get most of the core sleep metrics for free, including sleep duration, stages, score, restlessness, heart rate, and breathing quality. Since you can log meals, stress, alcohol or caffeine consumption and more, AI Coach can pick up on potential triggers for poor sleep, like having coffee too close to bedtime, and bring them to your attention.

Like the Apple Watch, the Pixel Watch 5 puts all sorts of other features on your wrist, from notifications to controlling smart home devices, and even answering questions via Gemini voice assistance. If you want those bells and whistles, it’s worth getting.

It’s a shame that … It isn’t a huge step up from the Pixel Watch 4. The 40-hour battery life means you need to charge it every day and a half. And you need a Google Health Premium subscription to unlock deeper sleep analysis. It also does not natively work with the iPhone.

Finish options: Matte Black, Polished Silver, Satin Pyrite, Champagne Gold

Battery life: Up to 30 hours, 48 hours in Battery Saver mode (41mm), up to 40 hours, 72 hours in Battery Saver Mode (46mm)

Subscription: Google Health Premium, $10 monthly or $100 annually (optional)

Best for no subscription:
Garmin Cirqa

View image in fullscreen Photograph: Christine Persaud/The Guardian

Best for no subscription:
Garmin Cirqa

$200 at REI $200 at Amazon

If you hate the idea of paying a monthly fee, the Garmin Cirqa works great without a subscription and also excels at tracking workouts.

Why we love it: The Cirqa offers accurate sleep tracking, activity tracking and vitals for one low price of entry. Garmin does technically offer a subscription service called Connect+, but it’s not worth it for most people and doesn’t offer any advancements in sleep tracking.

While thicker and wider than others, wearing the Garmin Cirqa is still comfortable. The battery lasts up to 10 days, and the two band sizes can accommodate wrists of any size.

As for accuracy, this band tracked closely with the Oura on light sleep, and fairly close on deep sleep, REM and HRV. Like the Fitbit Air, awake times are its biggest weakness, as it consistently recorded significantly less awake time.