Greens leader David Shoebridge says changes to defence laws could result in people participating in peaceful protests at the controversial signals intelligence base Pine Gap site being jailed. Photograph: Terry Trewin/AAPView image in fullscreenGreens leader David Shoebridge says changes to defence laws could result in people participating in peaceful protests at the controversial signals intelligence base Pine Gap site being jailed. Photograph: Terry Trewin/AAP

Concerns peaceful protesters and ordinary Australians taking photos near defence sites could face jail or hefty fines under proposed legislation

Get our daily political email, free app or daily news podcast

New laws criminalising photographs of defence sites and giving security officials the ability to search and detain people suspected of trying to enter designated zones are expected to pass parliament this week.

Some fear the powers could be used against legitimate protesters or unwitting everyday Australians.

What is in the defence bill?

The “accelerating capability and protecting bases” bill was introduced in late October, subjected to a rapid inquiry, and passed the Senate on Thursday. It is expected to become law after it passes the lower house in the final sitting week of the year.

It would criminalise entering or photographing a defence security zone or a person or thing in, entering or leaving it, with a maximum penalty of up to seven years’ jail time, a $152,880 fine, or both.

The security zones can include regular defence bases, but can also extend to emergency, temporary or mobile sites as decided by a minister – meaning they could include a military vehicle travelling on a public road.

Australia has a reputation for being the most secretive democracy in the world. New laws could make it worse | Tom SulstonRead more

What is in the defence bill?

The “accelerating capability and protecting bases” bill was introduced in late October, subjected to a rapid inquiry, and passed the Senate on Thursday. It is expected to become law after it passes the lower house in the final sitting week of the year.

It would criminalise entering or photographing a defence security zone or a person or thing in, entering or leaving it, with a maximum penalty of up to seven years’ jail time, a $152,880 fine, or both.

The security zones can include regular defence bases, but can also extend to emergency, temporary or mobile sites as decided by a minister – meaning they could include a military vehicle travelling on a public road.

The offences are paired with strict and absolute liability offences, which means it’s not necessary to prove a person’s intent, knowledge, recklessness or negligence.

The bill also gives defence security officials and law enforcement the power to search a person and their devices, with or without consent, and detain them if they have “reasonable suspicion” they are entering a defence zone.

Reasonable force can be used if it is necessary to prevent serious injury or death.

The laws also allow people to assist security and law enforcement and authorise them to “effectively do anything” they are asked in responding to an incident. These can include defence public servants, contractors, consultants and foreign military personnel.

View image in fullscreenThe USS Colorado, a Virginia-class nuclear-powered submarine at HMAS Stirling in Perth. Photograph: Richard Wainwright/AAP

The minister will also be allowed to make a “capability declaration”, allowing declared persons to engage in an activity – that must still be “reasonable and proportionate” but might otherwise be illegal under federal or state laws.

Some conduct is exempt from this power, including the threat or use of force, sexual offences, or other criminal acts other than what is specified within the declaration.

The assistant defence minister, Peter Khalil, said the reforms would “better equip defence to respond to increasingly complex strategic circumstances” and provide “fit-for-purpose and effective laws to safeguard the capabilities, people and infrastructure essential to Australia’s national security”.

Why are critics describing it as ‘draconian’ and a ‘war against democracy’?

Civil liberty groups and progressive politicians have condemned the bill as being an overreach of power, while others say it was rushed with limited time to review the changes.

The Greens leader, David Shoebridge, told the Senate the rules could result in people participating in peaceful protests at the signals intelligence base Pine Gap site being jailed.

“You are wanting to criminalise and jail and punish your fellow Australians because they might disagree with you,” he said.

“This legislation is going to war against democracy. It’s going to war against our own civil rights.”

In a submission to the short-lived inquiry into the bill, Digital Rights Watch warned the broad definitions could result in AI datacentres being designated as defence security sites and prevent people’s right to protest.

“We are concerned that there are insufficient safeguards to prevent the use of defence security zones to restrict communities’ rights to protest and resist the construction of AI data centres – effectively creating commercially-operated, US-owned Pine Gaps in suburbs across Australia,” their submission said.

The progressive thinktank the Australia Institute labelled it “draconian” and likened it to laws created under autocratic governments.

“This bill more closely reflects the ‘values’ of the Trump, Putin and Xi administrations. It stands in direct opposition to the values Americans themselves expressed at the midterm elections,” the institute’s security director, Emma Shortis, said.

Gender-diverse Australian sailors barred from US submarines despite Aukus deal, documents revealRead more

While the Liberals supported the aims of the bill, New South Wales senator Jess Collins said there hadn’t been enough time for parliament to review its implications.

“Strong powers demand strong safeguards and expanding ministerial authority demands stronger oversight,” she told the Senate.

“Where transparency is necessarily reduced in the name of national security, accountability must be increased rather than weakened.”

The Law Council of Australia similarly described the bill’s short review as a “rushed process” that increased the “risk of unintended consequences and poorly understood frameworks with less social licence”.

“The speed of this process does not reflect good law making and prevents many voices being heard,” president-elect, Elizabeth Shearer, said.

Why now?

The defence department said the strategic environment had changed but laws had not kept up.

“Existing legislative arrangements have developed incrementally and can be fragmented, resulting in different legal frameworks applying to similar activities,” a defence factsheet said.

“The reforms are intended to provide clearer and more coherent statutory frameworks to support contemporary defence activities while strengthening governance and accountability arrangements.”

The US now has access to more than half Australia’s military bases – could it drag the country unwillingly into war?Read more

But there’s also acknowledgment of the greater cooperation with foreign militaries, like the US.

Khalil said rapidly evolving and accelerating technological change required updated laws to protect the “security of defence personnel as well as the sites and the operations”.

“It will enable the national defence strategy and support Aukus while preserving clear limits, appropriate safeguards, independent oversight and accountability to the parliament and the Australian community,” Khalil said.

It comes as a report by Guardian Australia in September revealed the US military controls 17 facilities on mainland Australia and has access to 75 more Australian-run military installations.

Under the Force Posture agreement between the US and Australia, US forces and contractors have “unimpeded access to and use of” agreed Australian facilities, including for deploying forces and materiel, bunkering vessels and refuelling aircraft.

From next year, up to 1,200 uniformed US military personnel will operate from the HMAS Stirling submarine base near Fremantle.