‘The political, social and economic grievances driving support for One Nation are real. One Nation’s solutions to those problems are not.’ Photograph: Christopher Hopkins/AAPView image in fullscreen‘The political, social and economic grievances driving support for One Nation are real. One Nation’s solutions to those problems are not.’ Photograph: Christopher Hopkins/AAP

If we look beyond the talking points, it’s clear that the party selling itself to the battlers is in fact committed to selling out working people – wherever they are from

Earlier this week, One Nation’s migration policy disappeared from its website, only to be replaced by an updated platform announced via press conference on Wednesday morning.

By my count, this is the third iteration of One Nation’s immigration policy – if you factor in Pauline Hanson’s Press Club address in June and her later announcement of a 130,000 yearly arrival target, amid internal disagreements and contradictions.

The latest announcement involves an end to permanent parent migration, with an estimated $1bn in visa fees to be refunded to applicants, and parents already in the country to be rounded up and deported at taxpayers’ expense. Another plank involves the reduction of humanitarian intake to 2,000.

‘Devastating consequences’: One Nation plan to slash Australia’s refugee program denouncedRead more

At this point, it has become trite to observe that One Nation’s immigration policies are as cruel as they are unworkable. Abruptly closing parent visas would permanently separate families who have been waiting decades to be reunited. It would mean that future generations would not have the chance to live with their Nonna or Nonno, their Dadi or Dada, the way so many of us did.

Slashing humanitarian numbers will leave thousands of people – including the victims of wars that Australia has waged – stranded both overseas and on our shores. It would involve, for instance, abandoning communities like the Yazidis who were systematically targeted by the Islamic State. One Nation’s Barnaby Joyce has previously expressed his personal solidarity with Yazidi refugees and actively encouraged them to settle in his electorate during the Morrison era.

Applied onshore, a rigid humanitarian cap wouldn’t block people from applying for asylum. Instead, it would mean that people entitled to refugee status would have to wait in a decades-long queue to be granted a permanent visa. During that time, they would be locked out of permanent jobs, prevented from setting down roots and making a home for themselves in Australia.

Hanson says the proposals would save the government $141bn over 10 years but admits they haven’t been costed. The absence of critical details and evidence is to be expected if we accept, as we should at this point, that One Nation’s migration policy has nothing to do with immigration at all. Rather, it is about providing thin populist cover to a political program shaped by billionaire interests and hostile to working people across the country.

Just as its net migration targets were said to be about protecting “Australian jobs,” Wednesday’s announcements were sold to the public as a tough but fair attempt to “look after Australians first”. But if we look beyond the talking points, it’s clear that the party selling itself to the battlers is, in fact, committed to selling out working people – wherever they are from.

What will these “Australian jobs” look like, in a future society where One Nation has successfully deported 75,000 people (and perhaps even managed to exclude some of the rest of us who were born overseas)? One Nation’s voting record provides the answer.

Does Australia really have the world’s second most generous refugee scheme?Read more

In federal parliament, One Nation has consistently voted against measures that would improve the lives of working people. One Nation voted against measures that would have strengthened the rights of casual workers to secure permanent jobs. It voted against a “same job, same pay” proposal that would have ensured pay parity between contractors and permanent workers. It opposed paid parental leave, on the basis that women “get themselves pregnant” to access entitlements. And when this voting record was put to Hanson at the Press Club, she said businesses had complained to her about workers being lazy and “on their phones”.

The same case can be made about any part of One Nation’s voting record. When it comes to housing affordability, One Nation wants to reintroduce investor discounts that have put home ownership out of reach for many working people. On healthcare, One Nation wants to limit abortion, shifting the physical and psychological cost on to women.

The political, social and economic grievances driving support for One Nation are real. One Nation’s solutions to those problems are not. They rely on a simple, base political assumption: that ordinary people will not look beyond their immediate patch – their family, their neighbourhood – and realise what they have in common with one another.

As we face down the dystopian proposal of rounding up and deporting grandmothers, we can show that we are better, and smarter, than that.