Slain former ANCYL Secretary-General Sindiso Magaqa.

Slain former ANCYL Secretary-General Sindiso Magaqa.

The trial of three men accused of murdering former ANC Youth League secretary-general Sindiso Magaqa started last week with hope of a swift resolution, and ended with another delay this week.

Just seven days after Mbulelo Mpofana, Sbonelo Myeza and Zweliphansi Stanley Skhosana pleaded not guilty in the Pietermaritzburg High Court, the case was derailed again, this time by a bid to remove the two prosecutors leading it.

Last-minute recusal bid stalls case just days after not-guilty pleas

Skhosana, accused number three and the former uMzimkhulu Municipal Manager, is asking the court to recuse Deputy Director of Public Prosecutions Adv Lawrence Gcaba and Senior State Advocate Elvis Gcweka from the trial.

His lawyer, Adv Simphiwe Mlotshwa, told Judge Mluleki Chithi on Monday that he had only finished drafting the papers over the weekend because he had been busy with examinations during the week.

The State immediately said it would oppose the application.

Gcaba told the court the move had not been raised at any of the pre-trial conferences, including the last one on November 5, and questioned why it was only being launched now, just as the State was ready to start leading evidence.

Judge questions timing

Judge Chithi also raised concern. He said the trial had already been delayed for a long time and that it was almost a decade since Magaqa died.

He reminded the defence that the break from last week to Monday was given precisely to deal with issues like this and questioned whether the application was appropriate, given that Skhosana had already pleaded.

No details of the recusal application were read out in court.

What happens next in the nine-year battle for justice 

A timetable was then set: the State was to file opposing papers by Wednesday, the defence to file heads of argument by November 23, the State replies on November 24, and the application will be heard on November 25.

Gcweka told the court last week that four witnesses in the matter have already died, while others have been in witness protection for more than six years and are growing tired.

Magaqa was shot on July 13, 2017, a few kilometres from his home in Ibisi, uMzimkhulu. He died in hospital two months later.

Mpofana, Myeza and Skhosana face charges including conspiracy to commit murder, murder, attempted murder, unlawful possession of a prohibited firearm, unlawful possession of a firearm and ammunition, and malicious injury to property. Skhosana faces an additional charge of defeating the administration of justice.

All three deny the charges. Former policeman Myeza and businessman Mpofana are out on bail, while Skhosana remains in custody.

A fourth man, Sibusiso Ncengwa, is already serving 25 years after pleading guilty in June 2025 to his role in the killing. He admitted he was part of a group paid about R500,000 to kill Magaqa, who was targeted for speaking out against a corruption-riddled tender to construct a local memorial hall.

The trial was meant to run from November 9 to December 11.