Where to now for Sydney and AFL football? Players need to be asked some uncomfortable questions for a start
In August, as the Sydney Swans scandal unfolded, I asked a question: what exactly are we angry about?
Now police have announced no criminal charges will be laid. That matters. Allegations are not findings of guilt, and the players must not be treated as though they have committed crimes. Nor does a decision not to charge settle every question about what happened. Any continuing legal proceedings deserve care rather than speculation.
But the absence of criminal charges does not mean the absence of standards.
The public response was loud, but not everyone was responding to the same thing. Some football people saw foolish, unprofessional behaviour that was hardly unfamiliar. Many women saw men bonding through the sexualisation of women. Parents worried about the example set when sporting talent seems to excuse poor choices. The Swans themselves judged the conduct to have breached their standards and suspended players.
Police decide not to charge Sydney Swans players over incident in Melbourne hotelRead moreFor those of us who have spent years working to change sporting cultures, there was something encouraging about the response. Behaviour that might once have been laughed off was being questioned, and a club was prepared to act. That’s progress. It doesn’t mean every public judgment was fair, or that anyone who raised questions was alleging criminal guilt.
But now we have to ask what, exactly, football wants to stop happening again.
Even among people who agree that poor judgment was exercised, there is little agreement about which decision was poor. Was it staying out until 2am with an 8am flight to catch? Was it engaging adult entertainers? Was it the circumstances in which they were engaged? Or, for some, was the real mistake simply that the night became public?
Those are different objections. They rest on different ideas of professionalism, respect and responsibility. If we tell players to use better judgment, without explaining what we mean, we leave them to guess where the line sits.
And here’s the thing: clarity doesn’t require everyone to agree.
A club can decide that being out at 2am before an early flight is unacceptable, even if some players think it’s harmless. It can set expectations about team celebrations even if similar activities have been common for decades. It should explain the reasoning, listen to players, make its standards reasonable and apply them consistently. But it cannot outsource its values to whoever is loudest in the room or online.
View image in fullscreenJames Jordan, Chad Warner, Isaac Heeney and Nick Blakey. Composite: AFL Photos/Getty ImagesHaving worked inside sport and with teams on culture and behaviour change, I’ve seen the distance between the rules organisations write down and the ones people actually live by.
The written rules say respect others, show professionalism, exercise good judgment. The unwritten rules say don’t spoil the fun, don’t challenge the senior players, don’t be the one who makes things awkward. Sometimes the unwritten rule is simply: do what you like, just don’t get caught.
If that is the lesson from this episode, nothing meaningful changes. The same behaviour just moves somewhere less visible.
What struck me in conversations after the story broke was how routinely strippers and topless waitresses were described as part of sporting celebrations, across community and elite environments, among players and administrators. It was almost presented as inevitable: blokes get together, let off steam, and naked women somehow become part of the occasion.
skip past newsletter promotionafter newsletter promotion
AFLW star who is also paramedic nurse leaps into action to help rival after ‘really scary’ head clashRead moreBut why? Men in plenty of communities and cultures celebrate, bond and commiserate without sexualised entertainment. How did this become such a familiar ritual in parts of Australian sport?
And do the men involved actually want it? Or have generations simply inherited an idea of what men are supposed to do together?
A young player joins a club wanting to belong. He watches the senior players, notices what gets a laugh and learns what earns approval. Nobody has to tell him the rules. He picks them up by watching.
That doesn’t mean adult entertainment is inherently unlawful, or that sexualised celebrations inevitably lead to sexual violence. It means we can ask whether these rituals reflect the values clubs claim to hold. We can also ask whether everyone really feels free to say no. If fitting in depends on joining in, what looks like bonding to one person might feel like pressure to another.
So the work ahead is not another presentation telling players to make good choices. It’s getting specific about which choices, in which circumstances, and why.
I’d start by sitting down with players and asking uncomfortable questions. What is acceptable on a team trip? Who decides what counts as fun? What happens if someone opts out? Can a younger player question a senior teammate? What happens when an influential player says nothing? Which behaviours do we condemn publicly but quietly tolerate in private?
Then I’d work with the people who really set the tone. Not only captains and formal leaders, but the popular players whose approval carries weight. They can reinforce an old ritual without thinking, or make it easier for somebody else to choose differently.
Sydney Swans engage external advisers to review embattled AFL club’s cultureRead moreThis requires more than compliance. Players need to understand the reasoning behind expectations and have practical ways to act on them. Make opting out ordinary. Make speaking up possible without humiliating a teammate. Make it clear that protecting the group’s reputation is not the same as protecting its culture.
And I’d encourage football to do something that might sound odd coming from someone who works in governance: break the rules.
Not the workplace rules that protect people. The unwritten rules we’ve inherited without questioning. The rule that you must join in to belong. That challenging a mate makes you disloyal. That something is fine because it’s always been done. Above all, the rule that the problem isn’t what happened, but that somebody found out.
I started by asking what we were angry about. Now I’d ask what we actually want to change.
Because the test of football’s progress won’t be whether players learn to stay out of the headlines. It will be whether they make different choices, even when nobody is watching.